The Jewish Chronicle

Knesset votes to close shops over Shabbat

- BY ANSHEL PFEFFER IN JERUSALEM

ISRAELI MKS have narrowly approved proposals that allow the interior minister to close supermarke­ts and grocery shops on Shabbat.

The Knesset passed the bill, proposed by the Strictly Orthodox party Shas, in the early hours of Tuesday morning by a majority of one, following months of wrangling and a debate lasting 15 hours.

It means Shas leader and Interior Minister Arye Deri can now order local authoritie­s to close shops in their area between Friday and Saturday nights, although it is unclear whether he will actually move to enforce it.

Many mayors and local council leaders oppose the law. They say it is unenforcea­ble, since they cannot send Jewish inspectors out on Shabbat to check whether shopkeeper­s are keeping their businesses open.

Opposition parties Meretz and Yesh Atid are planning to petition the High Court, claiming the law is unconstitu­tional because it “forces all Israelis to adopt a religious lifestyle.”

Mr Deri tweeted after the law passed that it was “not a ‘Charedi victory’.”

“It is keeping the status quo and a victory for the silent majority in Israel who want to preserve the Jewish character of the state,” he said.

The law also illustrate­d the present state of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s right-wing coalition, in which each party can force the rest to vote for its pet laws.

Yet the government’s majority for the Shabbat law was in jeopardy after the members of Yisrael Beiteinu, a right-wing party that objects to religious laws, voted against it.

Two other coalition MKs rebelled against the whip but were absent.

The coalition succeeded in mustering enough members to win 58-57 in a vote that finally took place at 2.15 am.

The law was drafted after the High Court ruled last year that the government did not have the power to dictate to local authoritie­s over trading on Shabbat.

In the face of opposition from local politician­s, the law became a symbol for Strictly Orthodox parliament­arians wanting to ensure “the Jewish

character” of Israel’s public spaces. Many Likud lawmakers, ministers and mayors admitted openly that the law was unrealisti­c and could harm them with voters.

But Mr Netanyahu ordered the coalition whip David Amsalem to deliver a majority in an effort to please Charedi parties.

Likud whips went as far as to initiate expulsion procedures against one dissenting MK, Sharen Haskel.

Mayors claim they cannot enforce the law

 ?? PHOTO: FLASH 90 ?? United Torah Judaism MK Moshe Gafni at the parliament­ary vote, which ended at 2.15 am on Tuesday
PHOTO: FLASH 90 United Torah Judaism MK Moshe Gafni at the parliament­ary vote, which ended at 2.15 am on Tuesday

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom