What is a spot-kick now?

PENALTY 1

Ryan Shawcross (No17) pays the price for roughing up Nicolas Otamendi as Stoke defend, but the City player seemed to be taking as much of his opponent’s shirt

PENALTY 2

Shawcross tangles with Raheem Sterling, who isn’t looking at the ball. But it is a physical mis-match and the City winger barely impedes his Stoke rival. Referee Mike Dean had no hesitation, however, in awarding the penalty

AND SHOULD THIS HAVE BEEN PENALTY 3?

Joe Allen hits the deck under a challenge from Aleksandar Kolarov (centre), who pushed him in the back of the neck