BBC show ignored poll saying most don’t want change in abortion law
THE BBC has suppressed an ‘inconvenient’ survey that showed the British public has a conservative attitude to abortion.
Pollsters ICM found no widespread support for scrapping abortion laws in research commissioned for the BBC2’s Abortion On Trial.
But when the show, hosted by Anne Robinson, aired last Monday, there was no mention of the result.
Instead, producers‘ cherrypicked’ results which support a radical campaign to decriminalise abortion – a move which would end the 24-week time limit on terminations for so-called ‘social’ reasons.
Tory MP Fiona Bruce, who chairs the All Party Parliamentary Pro Life Group, said: ‘How can people be expected to have a fair and proper debate if facts are suppressed? It undermines credibility to cherry-pick polling results to reflect a lobby to which programme makers may be sympathetic.’
The hour-long programme was recorded at Ms Robinson’ s Gloucestershire home and involved a debate between nine people who held different views on abortion. Publicity material said: ‘For every key issue her guests discuss, Anne examines how their views compare to those of the wider public.’
But the programme failed to mention ICM findings on several subjects discussed, including that:
The British public strongly favours the current law of requiring two doctors to approve an abortion, over moves to weaken this;
Only a minority think the wom- an’s ‘right to choose’ is paramount – while most disagree with terminating on the grounds of disability;
A huge majority object to abortion based on the foetus’s gender.
However, the programme did highlight the belief, erroneously held by 69 per cent of the public, that abortion is ‘completely legal if the woman requests it’. During the broadcast, Lord Steele, architect of the 1967 Abortion Act said: ‘Perhaps the time has come to revisit the legislation of 50 years ago and decriminalise it completely.’
Abortion rights activist Diane Munday called for the same – and backed sex-selective abortion. Neonatologist Neena Modi suggested the 24- week limit, based on the chance of a foetus surviving outside the womb, should be dropped, saying the key issue was whether a woman felt ‘abortion is warranted’.
Parts of the medical establishment, including the Royal College of Midwives and the British Medical Association, also want the 24-week limit lifted. No experts were filmed giving alternative viewpoints, despite the BBC’s head of religion and ethics, Fatima Salaria, promising an ‘impartial’ programme.
Maria Caulfield, MP for Lewes and a former nurse, said: ‘I am concerned not all sides of the argument are being put across if the BBC ignores inconvenient poll results.’
Last night, the BBC said: ‘It is completely wrong to suggest that the BBC suppressed the results of the poll. They were released to the press prior to transmission, were referred to throughout the programme and have been published in full on the ICM website.
‘ The production team went to great lengths to ensure Abortion On Trial was fair and impartial, using expert consultants (both anti-abortion and pro-choice), including contributors representing a wide range of perspectives and experience.’
The corporation said it hoped the programme ‘was a starting point for discussion’.
THERE is no more irreconcilable division in our society than there is over the issue of abortion. We have dealt with this by designing a delicate compromise. Abortion stays illegal except under certain limits.
Opponents want more limits. Supporters want total decriminalisation. The BBC was right to reflect those divisions in a recent TV debate.
But it was a breach of its impartiality to fail to mention in the programme that its own poll had shown that more people answered ‘yes’ to the question ‘Do you think it is appropriate that abortion be considered a criminal matter’ than answered ‘no’.
Honest debate means admitting all the facts, not just those that suit your case.
Far too many at the BBC seem to think that impartiality only applies to the contest between Labour and Tory parties at General Elections, and that they are free to push generally Left-wing agendas at all other times and on all other subjects.
That is not what the BBC Charter and Agreement say, and Ofcom, newly in charge of regulating such matters, should take this opportunity to hammer this message home.