‘Refreshingly frank’ article

SIR, – Many of your readers will have noticed that our SNP parliamentarians speak on issues in an almost parrot-like, disciplined fashion with minimal variation between speakers.

We get the impression that they are quoting a centralised line – almost like the edict of a totalitarian regime. This seems like a new type of political representation in Britain, and I feel adversely reflects on the ability of the MSPs to introduce their own ideas, produce a healthier discussion and move towards a better thought-out consensus.

Your article on “Obedient Adulation” last Saturday (The Press and Journal, July 23), which referred to the opinions of Alistair Bonnington (who taught Nicola Sturgeon law in Glasgow), has helped to add light to this question. To quote him on his reference to past legislation, “SNP MSPs slavishly followed orders, meaning government bills were afforded obedient adulation, no matter how flawed.” He went on, “This results in Scotland producing the lowest quality legislation in Europe.”

With refreshing frankness, Mr Bonnington confesses to some shortcomings in his own teachings with regard to our first minister, “Failing to instil in her the most basic rules of how the institutions of government work in the free world.”

Not everyone will agree with Mr Bonnington, but his comments make interesting reading. Bill Anderson, Cults,

Aberdeen.