Brexit talks choice

Nicola Sturgeon’s ongoing assertion that the Scottish Government should have a seat at the Brexit negotiating table naturally has been rejected – Holyrood’s remit is domestic. But how about Ruth Davidson instead?

Ms Sturgeon’s involvement would be as divisive as it would seem illogical. Can anyone imagine her constructively supporting, let alone strengthening, any Uk-wide negotiating stance? She’s a non-starter.

On the other hand, Ms Davidson adopting such a role is sensible from UK and Scottish perspectives. She’s close to the heart of the UK government and with increasing clout, post-election.

She won’t aim to undermine the UK, as Ms Sturgeon would, yet supports what she terms an “open” Brexit. Since Brexit must happen, Ms Davidson’s position most likely mirrors the views of the majority in Scotland. Yet she’s also mindful of Scottish sensitivities, such as the concerns of our fishing communities.

From Theresa May’s position it would demonstrate a receptivity to divergent views both from within the UK governing party and across the UK. It could be win-win for the Prime Minister – and let’s face it right now, Mrs May needs success in whatever guise it appears.

MARTIN REDFERN Merchiston Gardens, Edinburgh

Yet again Nicola Sturgeon used avoiding tactics to duck questions during the latest First Minister’s Questions.

She said, as she invariably does, that she would not take any lessons from those questioning her. This is then used as a link to the First Minister overturning the purpose of FMQS by instead of answering Ruth Davidson’s question about taking the threat of a second referendum off the table, choosing instead to fire back a question in relation to Brexit.

Time and again Nicola Sturgeon makes a mockery of this important element of how the Scottish Government is supposed to be held to account.

These tactics might have appeared clever back in the days when she was renowned for her debating skills at university, but they now simply belittle her office, and betray the principles of good government.

KEITH HOWELL West Linton, Peeblesshire