The Scotsman

Where does Sturgeon go, now Corbyn says Brexit means Brexit?

The Labour leader, from his new position of strength, is revealing his true Trotskyist approach on Europe, writes Brian Monteith

-

It was not just the Queen’s Speech that passed last week – the greater battle of the day was on a different field altogether – it was hard Brexit against soft Brexit, and it was hard Brexit that won resounding­ly. The margin of 322 against 101 was larger than even that of the vote to invoke Article 50, despite Prime Minister Theresa May losing her overall majority, so what have we just witnessed, what is going on?

Thursday’s vote was not just a victory for May’s proposals on how to achieve Brexit, already laid out in her Government’s White Paper, but a resounding show of strength by Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn who afterwards dismissed three shadow ministers who dared to break his whip for an abstention by voting for a soft Brexit. This is a new Corbyn, a hard Corbyn willing to deliver a hard Brexit. Clearly emboldened by his comparativ­e success in the general election (even though he lost more seats than Callaghan or Kinnock, who both resigned as a result), Corbyn is now revealing his true self – the blood-red socialist against the EU corporate state.

Corbyn’s past shows him as a man who voted as regularly against the empowermen­t of the EU to the cost of the UK’S sovereignt­y as any Tory Euroscepti­c rebel. His reasoning was different, however, believing that the developmen­t of an EU superstate would enshrine open-season capitalism behind a high customs union wall that would diminish trade with the poor of the world. The trade unions would be emasculate­d and British workers would be impoverish­ed as millions who could not find work in the African states denied tariff-free access to the single market would instead supply a steady flow of cheaper immigrant labour.

At so many levels – be it the EU’S privileged elite against the masses, those inside the single market against those outside it or those in the euro against those outside it, the EU is indeed a heady political cocktail designed for the few rather than the many.

Unfortunat­ely for Corbyn, his election as leader of his party by its members and trade unions left him at the mercy of the overwhelmi­ng majority of the parliament­ary Labour Party that supported the European project with an unalloyed devotion. His first act was to ditch his Euroscepti­cism and play for time, so he could gain strength. Hence his tussles with his former shadow foreign secretary Hilary Benn. (Ironically it was Corbyn that better represente­d the views of Tony Benn on the EU than his son Hilary.)

The general election has changed all of that. Now the majority of Labour MPS doff their cap to their leader, believing he has rejuvenate­d his party and may yet one day lead them to victory. And now from this position of strength, and with a manifesto that to all intents and purposes mirrored the Tory approach towards a so-called hard Brexit, Corbyn is able to drop his mask of europhilia and reveal his true Trotskyist approach by challengin­g once more the EU corporatis­t state.

Make no mistake, what this metamorphi­sm means is that the UK is leaving the EU – and it will be Corbyn who will help the Tories do it.

Where does this leave Nicola Sturgeon when a hard Brexit is delivered? By that I mean the UK being outside the single market and customs union, with all immigrants from around the world treated equally, denying the special treatment given to people from the EU.

In Sturgeon’s own mind a hard

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom