The Scotsman

Beware the Left

-

Tony Blair is right to advise us to beware an unrealisti­c Corbyn manifesto at the next election.

But this begs the question: “Why did so many top economists support Labour recently?” They saw that Leave’s victory was pyrrhic in the austerity atmosphere of Conservati­sm. People were promised that things would be better from Day 1, but the government wants to reserve spare cash for hard Brexit troublesho­oting.

This is too reactive a plan. SMES (small and medium businesses) need to produce a plan with major government help so they can get the technologi­cal and scientific knowledge and skills they need to get up to speed with competitor­s in other countries and get into exports. There have to be major training programmes to give us work skills we are losing as immigratio­n falls.

As business supply lines from Europe collapse we need an industrial strategy to create local supply lines. Brexit can be a huge opportunit­y for the UK to grow our way out of debt if we retool, have an investment bank and a strategic plan for infrastruc­ture developmen­t.

An unrealisti­c, hard Brexit with an insipid industrial strategy risks a massive permanent increase of our national debt by 2050. Tony Blair is right to want Brexit reversed at this time, precisely because like a Corbyn manifesto it may spiral us into Greek levels of debt. But he is wrong to think that a Neoliberal government can take us through it effectivel­y. If the Tories take a radical rethink, they might yet win moderate Labour voters to consider the unthinkabl­e – voting Tory.

ANDREW VASS Corbiehill Place, Edinburgh When Tony Blair speaks of the catastroph­ic effect on the UK of a populist right-wing controlled Brexit followed by a populist, unreconstr­ucted left-wing government led by Jeremy Corbyn, he raises the prospect of very real dangers. Our standard of living, public services, savings and affluence could well be decimated in those circumstan­ces.

Those of us who can remember the begging bowl proffered by the UK to the Internatio­nal Monetary Fund to bail us out of the then-government’s gross overspendi­ng and incompeten­ce will wince at the prospect. More than 40 years later the very same scenario becomes more and more likely. Let this comedy of errors please come to an end.

You do not need to like Tony Blair to know that he is speaking plain common sense.

ALEXANDER MCKAY New Cut Rigg, Edinburgh

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom