The Scotsman

Embryodeba­te

-

John Kelly (Letters, 8 September) suggests that abortion is killing “children”. Fortunatel­y no-one seriously suggests that children should be killed. An embryo (from fertilisat­ion to about the eighth week) is about the size of a kidney bean; it is not human in any sense of the word.

Embryos may abort spontaneou­sly without the mother being aware of what is happening. A foetus (from the ninth week) develops reflexes but only around the 20th week does it come close to resembling a baby that has the potential to grow into an adult; at that point it is no larger than a banana and could not survive independen­tly of its mother.

Thanks to modern technology we are able to keep alive many babies born after only 22 weeks, but many of these have severe health complicati­ons.

Women who end pregnancie­s before the embryo or foetus has a chance to survive do not do so lightly. To allege that they are killing children is intellectu­ally dishonest and creates unnecessar­y stress for the women involved.

I would have more respect for the anti-abortion lobby if it stopped using emotional language and confronted the real cause of abortions – contracept­ive methods that are not used or that fail.

MARTIN FOREMAN Craigend Park, Edinburgh

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom