U-turn on proxy votes for MPS as Johnson overrules Rees-mogg

Boris Johnson has bowed to pressure from angry MPS on all sides of the Commons to allow proxy votes for those unable to return to Westminster because they are shielding.

Less than 24 hours after Leader of the Commons Jacob Rees-mogg said MPS who couldn’t return to parliament for medical reasons would not be able to take part in votes, he was overruled by the Prime Minister.

There was widespread anger on Tuesday as MPS had to form a queue nearly 1.5km long, snaking around the parliamentary estate inside and outdoors, to walk through the Commons chamber for the first socially-distanced physical vote. The process initially took nearly 45 minutes, although it sped up at later attempts.

Around 200 MPS were not present because they or a family member are shielding, or due to difficulties in securing childcare and transport.

Ministers insisted that physical sittings are essential to allow proper scrutiny of the government, although 31 Conservative MPS rebelled yesterday seeking to extend hybrid virtual parliamentary debates.

Scottish MPS face particular difficulties travelling to and from Westminster every week, Orkney and Shetland Liberal

Democrat member Alistair Carmichael saying he has relocated to London for the next two months in order to take part in debates and votes.

Mr Rees-mogg had already made a concession in agreeing to allow shielding MPS to continue to take part in debates and put questions remotely, but insisted that they would only be able to be ‘paired’ in votes - an informal process where an MP voting the opposite way abstains, cancelling out an opposing vote.

But at Prime Minister’s Questions, Mr Johnson was challenged by Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer, who said: “The scenes yesterday of MPS queuing to vote, and members being unable to vote, were frankly shameful.

“If any other employer behaved like this, it will be a clear and obvious case of indirect discrimination under the Equalities Act - a clear and obvious case.

Mr Johnson defended putting a halt to virtual proceedings, telling Mr Starmer: “I do not think it unreasonable that we should ask parliamentarians to come back to this place and do their job.”

But the Prime Minister added: “I apologise to colleagues for the inconvenience, and I apologise to all those who face particular difficulties because they’re shielding, or because they are elderly, and the change we’re making today is that they should be able to vote by proxy.”