Campaigners win judicial review over gender definition
Campaigners have won the right to a judicial review over the definition of a woman in Scottish Government legislation aimed at improving representation on public boards.
The For Women Scotland ( FWS) organisation claims the definition in the Gender Representation on Public Boards ( Scotland) Act 2018 is outside the legislative competency of the Scottish Parliament and contravenes equality legislation.
They fear the Act has been used to bring in legal “selfidentification of sex” by the back door.
The Court of Session granted permission for the judicial review to proceed and a substantive hearing is now scheduled for January..
A spokeswoman for FWS said: "It should not be possible for Scottish Government to redefine Protected Characteristics in discrete legisla
tion nor undermine UK Equality law.
"Gove r n men t s a t Wes t - minster and Holyrood have, shamefully, ignored UK law a nd l e f t or di nar y women with the task of defending our legal rights at personal and financial cost. We object to the wholesale redefinition of women, which was done at the request of a lobby group, and without public consultation or Parliamentary scrutiny."
The Equality Act 2010 states "sex" is a reference to a man or a woman, and defines woman as "a female of any age".
The campaigners argue that maintaining this definition is key to "maintaining women's rights and protections in law."
It is feared that if it becomes established that devolved legislatures can amend key terms in the Equality Act via other pieces of legislation, then other countries within the UK may follow.
The Gender Representation on Public Boards Act was aimed at ensuring equal representation between men and women on public boards in Scotland.
But it states the definition of woman should include “a person who has the protected characteristic of gender reassignment ... if, and only if, the person is living as a woman and is proposing to undergo, is undergoing or has undergone a process ( or part of a process) for the purpose of becoming female."
The campaigners claim the Scottish Parliament has acted outwith its competence.