A Messiah with fresh ideas
SCO & Maxim Emelyanychev Usher Hall, Edinburgh JJJJ
For some, Handel’s Messiah is a Christmas piece. For the SCO and Maxim Emelyanychev, however, it’s clearly more of an Easter spectacle (as was its Dublin premiere in 1742). More arresting than simply locating the piece in the church calendar, however, were the ways in which Emelyanychev’s characteristically vivid account pointed up the work’s various connections with Christian festivities through its drama and storytelling.
Emelyanychev was bright, eager and dashing in the celebratory Christmas story of Part 1, launching the introductorysymphonywithsteely determination. Sometimes that enthusiasm went a little
too far: his dangerously fast “O thou that tellest” brilliantly captured an excitement at revealingthecomingofchrist, but also made countertenor Xavier Sabata’s supple, fluid singing feel rather breathless, and obscured some of the detail in the orchestra’s finely nuanced playing.
After Christmas celebrations came Easter tragedy, however,andemelyanychev’s speeds slowed and dramatic contrasts increased in Part 2. It was hard to ignore the contemporaryresonancesinbaritone Matthew Brook’s “Why do the nations so furiously rage together?”, sung with immense power and no little outrage, though the concluding “Hallelujah” chorus was beautifully buoyant rather than monumental. The SCO Chorus was on fine, resonant form when singing as a mass, but less powerful when split acrosshandel’sintricatecounterpoint.
If Part 1 was celebration and Part 2 was drama, Part 3 was far more contemplative, kickedoffbyaglowing“iknow thatmyredeemerliveth”from soprano Anna Dennis, whose agile, silvery voice was a highlight throughout the performance. It was a compelling account, full of character and big ideas – some more convincing than others, though Emelyanychev offered a distinctively fresh perspective on Handel’s choral warhorse.