Most likely a campaign-defining match for Scotland and England

◆ Townsend’s men have held upper hand in recent Calcutta Cup jousts but Red Rose look better under Borthwick’s leadership

When someone told Napoleon’s mother that she must be so proud to see her son as emperor, the old lady replied “so long as it lasts”. Considering our recent record in the Calcutta Cup, I know just how she felt. Perhaps Gregor Townsend does so too, for our recent record in the fixture is quite remarkable, unprecedented indeed, even in the years before the First World War when we beat England more often than not. So yes, one finds oneself echoing the old Corsican lady.

England seem in better shape than in recent years, principally because in Steve Borthwick they have a sensible and competent coach who, unlike his predecessor, doesn’t regard himself as the star of the show. His team is a nice mix of youth and experience.

Few of us this side of the Border were much impressed by England’s World Cup. They struggled in their pool and quarter-final, but then, on a vile wet night in Paris, came very close to beating South Africa, unlucky too perhaps. Since then they have beaten Italy and Wales. They may not have looked very impressive in either match, but one has the impression that Borthwick has made them harder to beat than they were in the Eddie Jones years.

Borthwick has made an interesting change at fullback, preferring George Furbank, a daring attacker, instead of Freddie Steward, who is as solid under the high ball as the Rock of Gibraltar but not so quick on the turn or so sure in fielding a low kick or bouncing ball. Still, the change makes it seem as if England will be more dangerous on the counterattack. Furbank has been in geat form for Northampton. There are some old stagers in the England pack but some lively young ones too; they have perhaps a better backrow than for some time.

What of us? There should be an element of savage indignation after the referee/ TMO cock-up which denied us a win against France, but cool heads are as important as fiery temper, and it is essential to keep the penalty count down; it was dreadful in Cardiff.

The team that Townsend has named is as near to a settled one as can be in the absence of the injured Darcy Graham and Richie Gray. The return of Jamie Ritchie is, one assumes, with an eye to speed and efficiency at the break-down, though it’s tough on Matt Fagerson. The line-out was good against France after being dreadful in Wales. The set scrum should be secure this afternoon, though referees’ interpretation is not something you can rely on.

Against France we made, I think, the mistake of protecting a lead that wasn’t big enough to be sure of protecting, and, after a brilliant try finished by Ben

Jamie Ritchie’s return today is designed to improve efficiency at the break-down. Left, England have made a surprise call by naming George Furbank

White, we seemed oddly reluctant to attack through the backs. One would hope to see more adventurous play. Likewise, there was an all too familiar refusal to move the ball away from the closequarter arm-wrestles near the try-line, though of course the last battering at the French line would have been justified if Sam Skinner’s try had been given.

The teams look fairly evenly matched to me and thegamehastheairofa season-defining one for both. England entertain Ireland at Twickenham next and then go to France. We are next in Italy where we have often found victory difficult, and then to Dublin where Ireland will be either going for a Grand Slam or licking unexpected wounds. All Six Nations matches are important, this one exceptionally so. It is quite likely that the loser today may end the tournament no higher than fourth in the standings.

I suppose most of us would be content with any sort of win, but let us hope for an attacking mindset. We play best when we look for space and move the ball as we did in the first half in Cardiff. Meanwhile, we have this extraordinary run against England to continue in the hope that Waterloo is some way distant. Looking back, one can think of many fine players who never tasted victory against the Auld Enemy.

We have this extraordinary run to continue in the hope that Waterloo is some way distant