Killer convicted 19 years after first Police interview
◆ Family finally wins justice for murdered daughter but questions remain as to why it took so long to charge Packer
Nearly two decades after the body of Emma Caldwell was found in an isolated woodland, a man who was interviewed in the initial investigation has been convicted of her murder and of being a serial rapist.
The unsolved murder was one of Scotland’s longest cold cases, and was branded a “scandal” by an ex-newspaper editor who exposed Iain Packer as the “forgotten suspect”, after which police and prosecutors reopened the inquiry.
The jury took four days to find Packer guilty of murdering the 27-year-old, who went missing in Glasgow on April 4 2005 and whose body was found in Limefield Woods, near Roberton, South Lanarkshire, the following month.
He was also convicted of indecently assaulting Miss Caldwell and raping nine women among dozens of sex offences spanning 26 years, following a trial at the High Court in Glasgow.
Packer, from the east end of Glasgow, was convicted of raping an underage girl in 1990, which the court heard during the trial was dismissed by the child’s family. He was first reported to police in March 1999 after a sex worker stole a tax disc from his vehicle to have proof of his identity after he raped her.
He preyed on “young, vulnerable and drug-addicted” sex workers in Glasgow’s red light area, and had a pattern of violent behaviour which included strangling women, the court heard.
Packer presented himself as a “jack the lad” who worked for a family business and enjoyed “treating women rough” and wore women’s underwear, according to one victim who was assaulted between 1993 and 2004, near the Tennent’s Brewery in the east end of Glasgow – the area where many attacks took place.
Miss Caldwell vanished on
April 4 2005, days after telling her mother Margaret about her hopes to kick a heroin addiction, which began following a family bereavement in her early 20s. She came from a close-knit family and saw both parents twice a week and spoke to them daily.
She was reported missing after she failed to respond to attempts to change a planned meeting with her mother. A dog walker found Miss Caldwell’s body in woodland, with a “garotte” around her neck, on May 8, 2005. Her father William, who died in 2011, made his family promise they would get justice for her.
Packer, who worked as a sign installer across Scotland, northern England and Northern
They actually gave licence to Iain Packer to continue his violence towards women Retired Det Sgt Mason
Ireland, was first interviewed by police on June 22, 2005 – and lied, telling officers he had never picked Miss Caldwell up and “could not help the investigation”, before telling further lies in interviews in 2006 and 2007.
The court heard Packer was a prolific user of sex workers who had described it as an “addiction”, and lied repeatedly to police and to a BBC journalist who interviewed him on national television in 2018.
During the trial, Packer admitted forcing a sex act on Miss Caldwell in August 2004 despite her telling him to stop, which he admitted was “criminal” and apologised for. A friend of Miss Caldwell told the court Packer “would not leave her alone”, while another sex worker gave a statement saying she was “petrified” of him.
Packer was investigated by the press in 2015 which caused the case to be reopened, and he admitted “instigating” an interview with BBC journalist Sam Poling in 2018 to “clear his name”, before claiming he had never visited the woodland. However, during his evidence at the trial, he admitted visiting Limefield Woods on six occasions including with Miss Caldwell – although prosecutor Richard Goddard KC said it was many more times.
A soil sample taken from the site where Miss Caldwell’s body was found was a “97 per cent match” with soil found in his blue work van after analysis in 2021, and Packer was charged in February 2022.
The jury was taken on a site visit to the isolated spot where Miss Caldwell’s body was found naked between two streams, in an area of woodland 40 miles from Glasgow.
Packer alleged he had never seen the specific location before, and blamed her murder on four Turkish men, later reducing it to two.
The four men were arrested in 2007, after a two-year surveillance operation on a cafe in Glasgow following interviews with other sex workers, but the case collapsed after issues with translation.
Packer lodged special defences of incrimination and consent, claiming many of the sex assaults were consensual, and that he had never met some of the women.
A complainant who was raped by Packer during a £30 transaction in 1998, which she agreed to due to financial pressures, eventually spoke to police in 2021, which she described as “the worst thing I’ve had to do in my life”.
Packer admitted in his evidence that he lied throughout seven police interviews and three BBC interviews, howev
er he told the court: “It wasn’t me who killed her. It wasn’t me. I didn’t do anything to her.”
Four former detectives who were involved in the earliest stages of the inquiry have said there is evidence Packer’s violent, abusive and predatory behaviour was known to police from the start of their investigation.
Retired Det Sgt Willie Mason said the decision by senior officers not to charge Packer earlier was catastrophic. He told the BBC: They’ve caused one of the worst injustices… the fact that they actually gave licence to Iain Packer to continue his violence towards women.”