Coroner’s fears after prisoner found dead
ACORONER has written to prison bosses to express his concern over welfare checks carried out on a murderer later found dead in his cell.
Nicholas Rose, 37, responded to a prison officer with a “grunt” hours before being found lifeless in bed – with policy saying inmates must reply verbally, his inquest in Bournemouth heard.
Rose, jailed for life in 2005 for killing teenager Charlotte Pinkney in Devon, died from airway obstruction, the aspiration of gastric content and intoxication of the drug spice at HMP Guys Marsh near Shaftesbury in Dorset on May 19 2019.
Brendan Allen, who sent his letter to the prison’s governor, said: “Evidence was heard that a ‘grunt’ in response to a welfare check is considered acceptable and fulfils the requirement for a ‘verbal response’.”
He said he is “concerned” that accepting a grunt does not go far enough, adding: “Such a response gives very limited information upon which a prison officer can assess a prisoner’s welfare.
“Accepting such a response potentially loses sight of the purpose of a welfare check, which must be to check that the prisoner is alive, immediately safe and well; that is, that they are conscious, breathing, not in a state of distress, not in a state of intoxication and that there are not any other factors that might require immediate intervention to prevent harm.”
Mr Allen said a “verbal response ... allows a prison officer to assess if a prisoner has responded in an appropriate manner, giving an indication as to whether the prisoner retains the cognitive function to provide an appropriate response”.
He added: “A ‘grunt’ does not allow such an assessment. Therefore, I have a concern that future deaths could occur if accepting such a response remains the accepted practice.”
Scaffolder Rose murdered 16-yearold Charlotte after driving her from a house party in Ilfracombe in February 2004.
Prosecutors said he killed her and hid her body, which has never been found, after she rejected his sexual advances.
Rose, from Ilfracombe, claimed he dropped Charlotte off outside a community centre and never saw her again.
But he was convicted and ordered to serve at least 20 years in prison.
On the day he died, he was checked at around 8.30am, a report by the Prisons and Probation Ombudsman said.
He was found dead when a lunchtime roll call was done at 12.15pm, it said. The inquest jury returned a conclusion of misadventure.
The Prison Service was approached for a comment.