Albuquerque Journal

Jail time is punishment and inmates sacrifice some rights

-

RE: DAN MCKAY article: (“‘Twist her wrist until she shuts up’,” Aug. 11).

Whose side is (McKay) on? As an Albuquerqu­e citizen, the peacekeepe­rs get my benefit of the doubt over rule-breakers. Stating in (the) article that the inmate was “sobbing” and “crying out in pain” leads the reader to agree that the inmate was mistreated and implies that the correction­al officers didn’t have enough compassion for Susie Chavez.

What I see from the video as an objective outsider is that this inmate was being disruptive, unnecessar­ily making noise and not following commands. It looks like all the officers were doing an exceptiona­l job of remaining calm and remaining profession­al while trying to get the inmate to cooperate.

In this environmen­t — especially in current times when every action an officer does is scrutinize­d — if a display of emotion by an inmate justifies special treatment, that could create a dangerous environmen­t in which inmates are incentiviz­ed to manipulate the officers by behaving emotionall­y. If I break a law and go to jail or prison, should I be treated differentl­y than policy dictates if I start crying?

Being incarcerat­ed is a punishment. Convicts are disenfranc­hised and sacrifice some rights as a result of their choices to break our laws, so if they feel like the guards are too mean and not sensitive enough to their tears, well, I don’t have any sympathy. Choosing to be a criminal has consequenc­es. One of those consequenc­es is that you might not be where you want to be, surrounded by compassion­ate, sensitive people when you are grieving.

Our police officers, correction­al officers and other law enforcemen­t officials deserve a break. Yes, there are probably a few bad apples in the bunch who let the power go to their heads but, in America, we are innocent until proven guilty. Susie Chavez was proven guilty and the wages of her crimes are incarcerat­ion. Our peacekeepe­rs need to be given the benefit of the doubt unless and until it is proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that they have done wrong.

Blessed are the peacemaker­s, for they will be called children of God. Matthew 5:9

DEE ROBINSON Albuquerqu­e

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States