Albuquerque Journal

Republican­s have already compromise­d high court

-

THE RECENT column by several former state attorneys general warning against increasing the size of the United States Supreme Court beyond its current nine justices, lest its “independen­ce” be compromise­d, would be a bit more persuasive if it had at least noted some recent events that have already done so.

First, the Supreme Court decided the 2000 presidenti­al election in favor of George W. Bush by a 5-4 partisan vote, using a power that the Constituti­on certainly does not seem to envision.

Second, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell decided to pack the Supreme Court by refusing to even hold hearings on former President Barack Obama’s nomination of a well-regarded moderate jurist, Merrick Garland. This left the court with only eight justices for many months.

Third, since the election of President (Donald) Trump, Sen. McConnell has made no secret of his intention to pack the federal judiciary in a highly partisan manner, based in no small part on the number of openings that were available to President Trump due to Sen. McConnell’s refusal to even consider many of Obama’s nomination­s to the federal courts during the last years of his term.

The independen­ce of the federal judiciary as a co-equal branch of government is indeed crucial to our constituti­onal system. Republican efforts in recent years have compromise­d that independen­ce.

JACK TAYLOR Albuquerqu­e

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States