Workers suffer as India tea estates close
BUNDAPANI, India — Deprived of health care and food rations, workers who had been scraping by on $1.50 per day at the Bundapani tea estate were left with nothing when it closed.
Bundapani’s owner failed to raise the alarm as hundreds of workers slid toward catastrophe.
“I have become like a beggar,” said Ramesh Mahali, 59, struggling to stand. He has been unable to properly feed himself or his family since the closure. His wife, Puliya, seeming 20 years older than her 50, sat emaciated on the floor.
Seven workers died in the two months it took the government to become aware of the crisis, and the toll has continued to climb since. In the past year, at least 69 tea workers have died across Bundapani and four other shuttered tea plantations in West Bengal, according to the Right to Food campaign, an advisory committee to the Supreme Court that is monitoring the deaths.
More than 16,000 people have been left in extreme poverty at the estates, spread across the Dooars plains below Darjeeling, source of the famous brand known as the Champagne of teas.
The government has begun offering emergency food and medical relief, but conditions remain grim. Despite the aid, 14 people at Bundapani alone have died in the past eight months, either from malnutrition or inadequate medical care.
If the plantation had not closed, “these people would not have died,” said Anuradha Talwar, a Right to Food activist. “These people are in a situation where they cannot afford basic things essential to survive.”
In estates visited by The Associated Press, many workers were clearly underfed and a number of them suffering from diseases commonly related to malnutrition, such as tuberculosis. Many were skipping meals. The food aid — slightly more than 4 pounds of rice per week — falls below standard rations at refugee camps.
The workers’ situation highlights how eastern India’s tea industry has changed little since colonial times. The government has done little to penalize owners who abandon their workers, who in practice often depend on estate-owners’ good will for survival.
“This is kind of the last hangover of a straightforwardly colonial relationship,” said Harsh Mander, special adviser on food to India’s Supreme Court.
Tea covers most of the plains under Darjeeling: miles of cropped green bushes, like a giant hedge maze.
Established by the British in the 1830s, the plantations became an essential image of an empire, relying on indentured laborers. Workers now have the right to leave and access to free primary education, but their dependency on the estates for housing and food means that, in practice, little has changed.
There are tea plantations in other Indian states, including Assam and Kerala, but West Bengal’s are widely seen as having the worst labor conditions. Most of its 200,000 tea workers are paid $1.50 per day, about 75 percent of the state minimum wage and below the U.N.’s $2-a-day threshold for extreme poverty.
To survive, workers rely on additional benefits from the plantations, including food, housing and medical care, valued at $1 per day. After a closure, the health care and food rations disappear.
The five closures are being largely blamed on mismanagement. Although West Bengal’s tea industry has declined recently, most plantations are functioning normally.
Owners have been prolonging the closures by engaging in lawsuits that prevent their plantations from reopening under new ownership. India’s clogged court system means these challenges can take a decade.
Three of the closed plantations are owned by one man, Robin Paul, a Kolkata-based businessman who owns the Surendragnagar, Dharanipur and Red Bank estates.
When reached by telephone, Paul declined to comment.
Attempts to contact Bundapani’s owner, Rakesh Srivastava, and the owners of the other closed tea plantations were unsuccessful. Lawyers for Srivastava also refused to comment.
Bengal’s chief minister has asked the national government to take over closed estates using legislation that allows the seizure of unproductive plantations. M.D. Rizwan, the joint labor commissioner for West Bengal, said the regional government is also urgently negotiating to reopen the estates.