Voters back Iowa lawmaker on health bill rebuff
SIDNEY, Iowa — Rebuffing President Donald Trump and Republican leaders on their health care bill seemed like a major political misstep for U.S. Rep. David Young of Iowa, who quickly was punished by a political action committee linked to House Speaker Paul Ryan.
Nearly three weeks later, voters in Young’s southwestern Iowa district — Republicans and Democrats — say the GOP congressman made the right move.
Conservatives praised Young for his opposition to the bill that would have undone much of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, casting the GOP measure as far short of a full repeal. Democrats welcomed the legislation’s demise, fearful that the measure would have been devastating to the poor.
The Republican bill would have eliminated tax penalties for people who don’t buy policies, provided tax credits that would be smaller than the law provides for many lower-earning and older recipients, and cut Medicaid, which helps poorer people afford medical care.
In a setback for the GOP last month, Ryan abruptly withdrew the bill after Trump and the House leadership failed to persuade enough Republicans to back the legislation.
With Congress on a twoweek break, Young faced his constituents in his competitive district and told them the bill’s drafting was its key liability. He steered clear of discussing specific provisions he opposes.
“A bad process makes a bad policy. We have to slow down. We have to air this out,” he said.
Patrick Spencer, a 54-yearold farmer from far southeast Iowa, agreed with Young. “They rushed it through. They did it in the dark,” Spencer said. “I wouldn’t be very happy if I were in his position and I’d been left out of it.”
Democrat Dale Doudna thanked Young for opposing the bill. “I appreciated your stand on the health care act,” said the 69-year-old retired teacher from a north Des Moines suburb.
Trump, Ryan and other top Republicans nevertheless maintain that they want to fulfill the promise they made to GOP voters over seven years to repeal and replace the health care law, but agreement in the GOP remains elusive.
“We’ve not been able to get ourselves together to keep our commitment,” Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., told reporters Wednesday in Louisville. “I haven’t given up.”
David Roberts, a 50-yearold farmer from Sidney, told Young in the Fremont County Courthouse on Monday that the law by President Barack Obama’s administration has “completely failed” and “needs to be repealed completely.” Monthly insurance premiums for Roberts’ family of six have already doubled to $1,500 under the current law, he said.
“I don’t know who to fault [for the House bill failure], but they kept changing it toward the end. I was just hoping for a clean repeal,” Roberts said. “I just wish they had made it simple.”
For Young, it’s a balancing act in a politically diverse district and a presidential battleground state that Obama won in 2008 and 2012, and Trump easily captured in 2016.
Young wants to avoid angering Iowa’s older-than-average population and his district’s disproportionately low-income residents, both of whom could be hurt by the GOP bill. Thirty-seven percent of Iowa’s population is 50 years or older compared with the nation’s 34 percent, according to AARP.
Patti McKee, a 60-year-old Des Moines artist, pressed Young to oppose allowing Medicaid, the federally funded state-run health plan for low-income Americans, to be parceled into block grants for states to allocate as they wish.
According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, more Iowans risk losing their coverage proportionally under Medicaid than nationally, considering the state agreed to expand the program under the Affordable Care Act, and the federal expansion funding would dry up under the GOP bill.
“That’s not the way to do it,” she told Young, who supports block grants, during a meeting in Des Moines on Wednesday. “My concern is for those hundreds of thousands on Medicaid in Iowa.”
The Congressional Leadership Fund, a political committee linked to House GOP leaders, last month pulled campaign support for Young ahead of next year’s midterms, removing a campaign staff member it had sent to Young’s district to provide political help. The move was made after Young came out against the health care bill.
Council Bluffs Republican Jeff Jorgensen said he’s been wary of Young, in part because of comments the congressman made supporting aspects of the Affordable Care Act. There’s been chatter, but little action, about a potential Republican primary opponent for Young in 2018, he said.
“I’m certainly trying to like the guy,” said Jorgensen, a 59-year-old electronics engineer. “His was the position he needed to take. We’re satisfied with that. But there can’t be any part of Obamacare left in place.”
Young’s opposition to the bill seemed to have defused some of the tension that marked a suburban Des Moines meeting in February when hundreds shouted at him for an hour. On Wednesday, Trump’s budget proposal, gun control, clean water regulations and the looming vote to keep the government running took up a majority of the hour he spent with 50 Des Moines-area constituents in the Iowa State Fairgrounds cattle auction building.
But Spencer made clear that voters will be watching on health care.
“Their constituents are not going to let it get away from them,” he said.
“A bad process makes a bad policy. We have to slow down. We have to air this out.” — U.S. Rep. David Young , R-Iowa