Israel lauds aid cut to Palestinians
Politics, not results, behind U.S.’ move, agency chief says
YAD BINYAMIN, Israel — Israel’s prime minister on Sunday welcomed the U.S. decision to stop funding the United Nations agency for Palestinian refugees, accusing it of perpetuating a crisis that lies at the heart of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
The agency’s commissioner rejected such accusations, saying that the failure of political leaders to resolve the conflict has caused the refugee crisis to drag on for 70 years.
Speaking in southern Israel, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Sunday that Israel has taken in hundreds of thousands of Jews uprooted from homes in the Middle East and Europe.
“This is not what is happening with the Palestinians,” he said. “There they created a unique institution, 70 years ago, not to absorb the refugees but to perpetuate them.”
The U.N. Relief and Works Agency was founded after the 1948 war surrounding Israel’s creation to serve some 700,000 Palestinians who fled or were uprooted from their homes. Today, it provides education and social services to over 5 million people across the region.
Netanyahu said the funds withheld by the U.S. should be used to “genuinely help rehabilitate” the refugees. He claimed the number of refugees is much lower than the agency’s figures.
The U.N. Relief and Works Agency rejects the Israeli accusations that it is perpetuating the refugee issue. It says it operates under a strict mandate outlined by the United Nations, and says the refugee issue should be resolved as part of a broader peace agreement between Israel and the Palestinians.
In Jordan, the agency’s commissioner, Pierre Kraehenbuehl, blamed political leaders’ failure to reach a peace deal for the ongoing crisis.
“We are not mandated to deal with the politics,” he said during a visit to a school in the Whedat refugee camp. “It is the utter failure of the parties and the international community to resolve this conflict that explains why Palestine refugees are still refugees 70 years on. It has nothing to do with an [agency] perpetuation of that situation.”
The U.S. cut off some $300 million in funding to the U.N. agency on Friday, calling it an “irredeemably flawed operation.” The U.S. has in the past been the largest donor, providing roughly 30 percent of the agency’s budget.
The U.N. agency has warned the cuts could hurt its operations, including a network of schools that serves over 500,000 students.
“The investment in young boys and girls … [and] in opportunities for their future is an investment in stability and therefore preserves the opportunities for peace,” Kraehenbuehl said in an interview Sunday.
Kraehenbuehl defended the U.N. Relief and Works Agency’s fiscal discipline and the agency’s management, dismissing calls for reform from the Trump administration.
“I want to make it very clear here that [this decision] was taken, for my understanding, for reasons that are political in nature and has nothing to do with [the agency’s] performance,” Kraehenbuehl said. “I say this with great confidence because during meetings I had in Washington in November 2017, shortly before the first measures were taken, there was a lot of recognition and respect expressed from U.S. officials about the way that The [U.N. Relief and Works Agency] runs its operations.”
The agency has been appealing for donors and cut its workforce in the Gaza Strip last month.
Several countries promised to increase their donations to the cash-strapped agency, including Germany, Turkey, India, Indonesia and Malaysia, Kraehenbuehl said.
Despite securing additional funds from donors, the agency is still facing a $200 million dollar shortfall, Kraehenbuehl added, describing the current situation as “an existential crisis” for the agency.
The Palestinians have condemned the U.S. decision, saying the Trump administration is trying to force neighboring countries to absorb refugees and remove the sensitive issue from future negotiations.
In west Amman, dozens of people gathered in front of the agency’s office to protest the U.S. decision, carrying Palestinian flags and banners, with one of them reading “There is no alternative to Palestine except Palestine.”
Information for this article was contributed by staff members of The Associated Press; and by Nehal El-Sherif of Deutsche Presse-Agentur.