Scrapped Afghan site cost U.S. $103M, report says
The State Department wasted $103 million in an urgent effort to build a security compound in Afghanistan before abandoning the project with almost nothing to show for it, the agency’s inspector general said in a report issued Tuesday.
The project, which was terminated in early 2017, started three years earlier amid increasing security threats after President Barack Obama’s administration began a military drawdown in the country. Guards contracted by the Diplomatic Security bureau, which is responsible for protecting U.S. officials and facilities worldwide, were housed more than 2 miles from the U.S. Embassy in Kabul. The guards had to travel the distance four times a day in convoys.
To minimize the dangers, a replacement compound, called Camp Eggers, was selected about half a mile from the embassy, but it required extensive demolition and renovation.
The problems became apparent almost immediately and cascaded, the inspector general’s report said. Diplomatic Security, which had no experience managing such a large project, decided to modify the contract it had with Aegis Defense Services to provide guard services, even though Aegis had not overseen construction of anything bigger than a shooting range. An engineering consultant hired separately to review the plans warned that delays and cost overruns were inevitable.
But the consultants’ advice was repeatedly ignored. The State Department went ahead with the project, originally estimated to cost $173 million, “to construct the entire Camp Eggers compound in only 18 months in a war zone,” the report said.
Even amid delays and design changes demanded by the State Department, building materials were purchased and delivered, and more money was spent to store them.
Despite mounting concerns, the State Department officials overseeing the project failed to do much more than write “letters of concern,” according to the report.
The consultant suggested suspending payments to Aegis, but one U.S. official told the inspector general’s investigators that it was “a given we are going to let them off the hook.” That reluctance was partly to avoid further delays and concern that it could complicate the relationship with Aegis.
By the time the State Department pulled the plug in January 2017, the projected cost had ballooned to $315 million, and only 10% of the project had been completed. The plan now is to build housing for the guards on the embassy grounds. It is not scheduled to be completed until 2023.
The inspector general suggested that the State Department spell out the circumstances under which it will undertake construction projects and designate formal responsibility. The State Department disagreed, responding in a letter to the inspector general’s office that the doomed Camp Eggers project presented “very unique circumstance” and that no two projects are alike.
The report underscores how long the U.S. government has struggled to protect U.S. diplomats and service members based in Afghanistan, which is the longest war in American history.
On Monday, two U.S. service members were fatally shot and a third was wounded when an Afghan soldier opened fire on a group of Americans at a military base in a conflict-torn region of southern Kandahar province, Afghan defense and police officials said Tuesday.
The Department of Defense identified the two soldiers as Pfc. Brandon Jay Kreischer, 20, of Stryker, Ohio; and Spc. Michael Isaiah Nance, 24, of Chicago. They were assigned to the Army’s 82nd Airborne Division, based in Fort Bragg, N.C., a Pentagon spokesman said in a statement late Tuesday. The soldiers died in Tarin Kowt, in Uruzgan province, “as a result of wounds sustained in a combat-related incident,” the spokesman said. The incident is under investigation, he said.
According to Afghan officials, the shooter was wounded in return fire and taken into Afghan military custody. It was the first “insider” attack since November, when Brent Taylor, a major in the Utah National Guard and the mayor of a town in Utah, was killed by an Afghan soldier in Kabul.
No information was immediately available about the shooter except that he was an Afghan soldier.