Party’s Arizona efforts pay off
But Democrats face challenge in capitalizing on ’20 gains
PHOENIX — President-elect Joe Biden’s campaign credits its success in Arizona to the immigrant-rights and grassroots organizations that have been mobilizing Hispanics for nearly two decades. The fruits of their labor paid off in the traditionally conservative state, where changing demographics and suburban voters turning out to oppose President Donald Trump also worked in Biden’s favor.
But what that means for the future of Democratic candidates and how the party can capitalize on these gains will be tested in 2022 and 2024 — especially because there wasn’t a blue shift in statewide races or in some other parts of the country with large Hispanic populations.
“It was extremely important and extremely helpful to the campaign to be able to tap into that enthusiasm, to be able to tap into that incredible network. I think it made all the difference into turning Arizona blue,” said Jessica Mejia, Arizona director for Biden’s campaign.
A coalition of long-standing grassroots organizations known as Mi AZ started knocking on doors in July, eventually hitting 1.1 million homes, even in the hottest summer on record in Phoenix. They made nearly 8 million phone calls and managed digital and broadcast campaigns.
Their work is nothing new. In 2016, groups involved with Mi AZ helped get a minimum wage increase passed and get Sheriff Joe Arpaio, who had long targeted immigrants, voted out of office.
Driven by years of anti-immigrant propositions and legislation — such as banning bilingual education 20 years ago; forcing college students without legal status to pay out-of-state tuition in 2006; and passing Senate Bill 1070, the “show me your papers” law from 2010 — these groups have built a network of activists and voters who turned out in huge numbers.
Hispanics now account for 24% of eligible voters in Arizona, compared with 19% in 2012, according to the Pew Research Center.
Biden’s victory and that of Mark Kelly, who unseated Republican Sen. Martha McSally, are notable gains for Democrats. Biden is only the second Democratic presidential candidate to win Arizona since 1948. Kelly’s win gives the state two Democratic senators for the first time in nearly 70 years.
But a slew of Democrats who ran for the state Legislature and statewide races failed to gain enough traction. Biden also owes his victory to changing suburban demographics, with Republican areas shifting Democratic, and to American Indians.
In parts of the country where Democrats have long reigned, more Hispanics voted for Trump this year than expected, including areas of Florida and Texas. It was a lesson in the limits of the party’s grip on an increasingly diverse segment of voters.
And how or whether Democrats can keep that enthusiasm in the 2022 midterm elections will require a lot of work.
Chuck Rocha, a senior Democratic strategist, said the work by grassroots groups in Arizona helped Biden win. But he said it’s incumbent on campaigns to prioritize Hispanic voters by spending time and money in their communities consistently, not just right before an election.
Super PACs that target Hispanic voters are crucial, Rocha said, adding that his, Nuestro PAC, spent $4 million on ads in Arizona starting the last week of June, but that such spending is rare.
“I think Arizona is an example of the way to do things right, and it’s more than just the grassroots groups,” Rocha said.
He said Democrats will have to deploy similar tactics in other Hispanic-heavy areas of the country if they want to succeed in 2022.
“If you’re relying on a bunch of white consultants to Google-Translate you an ad and put it on Univision, that’s not a winning strategy,” Rocha said.
Antonio Arellano, interim executive director of Jolt, a Texas advocacy group that aims to grow Hispanics’ political power and mobilize young voters, said both parties need to invest more in their outreach efforts if they’re going to win an increasingly large and diverse constituency.
They have to hire people who come from and reflect their communities and stop treating them as safe bets, Arellano said.
“The parties know what they need to do; they’re just not doing it. They have outdated strategies,” he said. “The Latino electorate is incredibly young. In order to connect with them, they need to modernize civic engagement, and that requires an investment. … What we’ve seen is that Latinos are an afterthought.”
And Texas Democrats will face stiff competition in trying to sway Hispanic voters. Republicans attracted Hispanics in parts of south Texas, and they will try to replicate that success elsewhere.