The shutdown looms
House Speaker Mike Johnson, the obscure former backbencher vaulted out of the far-right field to Congress’ highest-ranking job just over two weeks ago, told Sean Hannity that the many Americans wondering about his worldview should simply “pick up a Bible” and read it.
My copy doesn’t say anything about funding the U.S. government (or foreign policy, climate change, LGBTQ+ rights, gun policies and much more). And MAGA Mike, as he’s affectionately dubbed on the right, must also be having a hard time locating the pertinent passage. He adjourned the House on Thursday for a long weekend, still without a funding plan that would avert the government’s shutdown Friday at midnight.
Johnson’s retreat followed days of huddling behind closed doors with his fractious colleagues. (There was no word on whether they consulted a Bible.) Here’s his problem, given the slim majority he supposedly leads: He can only lose a handful of Republicans on any piece of legislation, but no one wants to compromise, and virtually everything is unacceptable to one group or another.
Some of his far-right compatriots say they will cut Johnson some slack—certainly compared to former Speaker Kevin McCarthy, whom they ousted last month for cutting a stopgap deal with Democrats and President Joe Biden to avoid a shutdown—but their forbearance is limited. And now the clique of so-called moderates—vulnerable Republicans from districts Biden won or nearly did—has finally risen up against the dominant MAGA faction’s demands.
It seems fitting that the anti-government, politically amateurish House Republicans, after rejecting three seasoned party leaders to replace McCarthy, finally landed on Johnson, the least-experienced speaker since the 19th century. It’s clear that the MAGA disciple from Louisiana is not a serious legislator. Facing his first big test atop a divided government along with Biden and a Democratic-controlled Senate, Johnson is failing.
His majority plainly would be happier in the minority, where the members could wreak rightwing havoc without having the responsibility of managing the government they so loathe. They are incapable of making the compromises essential to democracy, even with each other.
At the rate House Republicans are going, voters a year from now could well free them and Johnson of their authority. For now, however, their governing ineptitude hurts the country.
Doug Heye, a Republican strategist, last Thursday
posted on X: “With all the political news this week”—bad polls for Biden, boffo off-year election results for his party, new developments in Donald Trump’s legal morass and another Trumpless Republican presidential debate—“what’s happening in the House may be the most under the radar AND have the most consequences.”
Heye wrote just after Johnson and his leadership lieutenants had, for the second time in a week, scuppered plans for a House vote on one of the 12 annual appropriations bills to fund government agencies and operations. They didn’t have enough Republican support. One of the bills, like several others pending, included an anti-abortion provision—after voters on Tuesday strongly favored abortion rights and pro-abortion-rights Democrats even in red states.
Swing-district Republicans rebelled. “I don’t know if these guys have cable,” said one, Rep. John Duarte of California, about the party leadership. “But if they watched the elections … the American people are about fed up with abortion regulations being stuffed into every aspect of their lives.”
As usual, House Republicans’ problems are self-induced. The government’s fiscal year began Oct. 1 and Republicans squandered the bonus time McCarthy bought them by warring over his replacement. Days away from a second shutdown deadline, rookie Johnson still has no apparent plan for another stopgap bill that he could pass, let alone for appropriations bills. And whatever Johnson and his extremist caucus do come up with will confront bipartisan Senate opposition.
Johnson has angered senators of both parties by his opposition to more Ukraine aid and by delaying emergency aid to Israel, gratuitously attaching a provision to the bill he knew Democrats would reject. As for devising another stopgap bill, Johnson floated one idea that Republican Sen. Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia dismissed as “confusing and difficult to manage,” and Democratic Sen. Patty Murray of Washington, chair of the Senate Appropriations Committee, derided as “the craziest, stupidest thing I’ve ever heard of.”
House Republicans are worse than the gang that can’t shoot straight. These folks shoot straight all right, into both feet. They’re a prime example of Mark Twain’s warning: “There is no education in the second kick of a mule.”
Perhaps Johnson could find a better aphorism for his plight in the Bible. Meanwhile, we do have this biblical reference, from his MAGA colleague, Rep. Troy Nehls of Texas: “I don’t think the Lord Jesus himself could manage this group.”