Calls grow for robot umps
After strike zone controversy in Game 5, issue at forefront
HOUSTON — From the box seats to the far reaches of the bleachers, all 40,000 umpires in the stands at Nationals Park were sure they could tell: Gerrit Cole’s fastball to Victor Robles missed the strike zone.
By at least an inch, clearly.
That’s not how Lance Barksdale saw it. He rung up Robles on strike three, leaving the Nationals rookie hopping mad, and soon the ballpark was filled with angry chants at the plate umpire.
With every pitch at the World Series hurtling toward that strike zone box superimposed on TV screens, the call gets louder and louder: Bring on the robot umps!
“That’s a hot topic,” Astros manager AJ Hinch said Monday. “This is a big stage to be talking about hot topics. I guess it’s always possible.”
“I think it’s a little naive to think that simply letting computers generate strike or ball,” he said, “it’s incredibly naive to think that there’s not going to be pitfalls in that scenario, as well.”
Shortly before Robles struck out, Nationals manager Dave Martinez was perturbed when a pitch by one of his relievers didn’t go his team’s way.
“C’mon, Lance!” he shouted from the bench. “It’s the World Series! Wake up!”
Several umpires heard that hollering in Iowa. They’d met in Des Moines to attend the funeral service for one of their own, Eric Cooper, who died two weeks after working the AL playoffs.
To remember their friend, they went to a favorite spot of Coop’s on Sunday night. Game 5 of the World Series was on, and soon the shop talk turned to the subject of robot umps.
“It did come up. And yes, it’s frustrating,” said Dale Scott, who umpired in the majors for more than 30 years and worked the World Series three times.
“We’re never going to beat technology,” he said. “But do you want a video game or a game played by human beings?”
MLB is exploring the possibilities. The Arizona Fall League, made up of baseball’s top prospects, used computers to call pitches over the past month.
Video quickly circulated of Giants youngster Jacob Heyward getting called out on a pitch that nearly bounced, then being ejected by a human ump for arguing. But the overall reviews weren’t bad.
No doubt there will be plenty of discussion about the robots in upcoming contract talks between umpires and MLB.
Series tied 3-3 Game 1: Game 2: Game 3: Game 4: Game 5: Game 6:
Game 7:
Meantime, what particularly peeves umps is that TV box.
Scott said the actual strike zone MLB uses to evaluate umpires isn’t the same. Especially on high pitches.
“Ours is much more accurate than what you see on TV,” Scott said. “Do you notice how the zone is the same for Aaron Judge and Jose Altuve? But people take what they see on TV as gospel”
Also, while the plate is 17 inches wide, the strike zone is three-dimensional. A curveball can clip the front and almost end up in the dirt, or hook down to catch the back part of the dish.
Consider this, too: What is a strike?
As in, suppose the ball shows up side-by-side with the outside edge of the box, but there’s no overlap. Ball or strike?
A day before his Astros took a 3-2 lead into Game 6 on Tuesday night, Hinch saw both sides of the debate.
“I’m always interested in improving the game. I’m interested in advancing things ...” he said.
“If we can better the game, I’m all for it. And perhaps that’s an avenue that we’re going to go down some day,” he said.
If that happens, Hinch had one more thought.
“Be careful what you wish for,” he said.