Baltimore Sun

Let’s find a better symbol of Italian pride than Christophe­r Columbus

-

The effort to make Christophe­r Columbus a source of pride for Italian Americans culminated in 1937 when Columbus Day was made a national holiday. It’s important, though, to recognize that this — like similar work on behalf of other groups — was connected to the “melting pot” myth that hailed the assimilati­on of immigrants into the general U.S. population with the understand­ing that the general population excluded African Americans (“Baltimore’s Columbus monuments drawn into debate as memorials fall around the country,” June 25).

Columbus, moreover, carries a burden that St. Patrick or Casimir Pulaski, for example, do not share. That is, Columbus appropriat­ed land from Indigenous people and took part in genocidal activities and in introducin­g racebased slavery to the Western Hemisphere. Surely there must be a historical character of Italian background more suitable to memorializ­e, in whom Italian Americans (and the rest of us) can feel some pride. I would suggest the Italian immigrant Arturo Toscanini who was among the greatest orchestral conductors of all time, not to mention a foremost anti-fascist.

Ed Morman, Baltimore

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States