Boston Herald

DRAW IRE OF CRITICS, EXPERTS

- — mary.markos@bostonhera­ld.com

children from parents who are criminally charged when entering the U.S. illegally.

“I don’t know if he understand­s the difficulty of every action he tries to take,” Capuano said. “It’s a political stunt, but it impacts people in a real way.”

Matt Cameron, an immigratio­n lawyer in East Boston who works with many people from Central America, including illegal immigrants, said Trump has been trying to get rid of judges and immigratio­n courts for years now.

“I would say he clearly has no understand­ing of due process, and we’ve known that,” Cameron said. “We should be more concerned that the CEO of immigratio­n doesn’t understand immigratio­n policy.”

However, Jessica Vaughan, director of policy studies for the Center for Immigratio­n Studies, said she sees Trump’s proposal as an attempt to vet out people who might try to take advantage of the system.

“It’s not necessaril­y a denial of due process. Not everyone is entitled to the same type of due process hearing before an immigratio­n judge,” Vaughan said. “We cannot continue to let people game the system. It’s gotten out of control.”

Petra Molnar, a researcher and refugee advocate in Toronto, questioned the legality of Trump’s proclamati­on, which she said contradict­s both U.S. and internatio­nal immigratio­n laws.

“If this is actually going to be written as policy or written into law, this is a perfect lawsuit,” she said. “It doesn’t make sense — you’re dismantlin­g a huge part of your immigratio­n system.”

Stephanie Silverman, a migration researcher and educator in the U.S., U.K. and Canada, doubted that what Trump has proposed is even possible.

“Deportatio­n is a two-way agreement,” she said. “A government has to accept them back — you can’t just drop somebody out of the U.S. … It doesn’t work like that.”

Silverman did agree with one part of his tweet, however, in saying that the U.S. system is “very unfair” to individual­s who wait years to gain legal entry.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States