In Kentucky coal country, an embrace of nuclear power plants
FRANKFORT, Ky. — Donald Trump promised to bring back coal jobs, but even the country’s third-largest coal producer appears to be hedging its bets on a comeback. Kentucky is on the cusp of doing what was once unthinkable: opening the door to nuclear power.
The Republican-controlled state legislature Wednesday voted 65-28 for legislation to lift Kentucky’s decades-long moratorium on nuclear energy in a state that has been culturally and economically dominated by coal.
Republican Rep. Steven Rudy said it would take a decade or more for developers to get a nuclear power plant operational in Kentucky due to the rigorous permitting process.
That didn’t satisfy Republican Rep. Jim Gooch Jr. He called Kentucky a coal state, and said the bill is a “kick in the teeth” to the coal industry.
But Gov. Matt Bevin said he would not veto the bill, if it reaches his desk.
“I don’t see it as a threat to that existing energy infrastructure. I see it as just increasing the opportunities of things we might be able to do in Kentucky,” he said.
Politicians from both parties have promised for years to revive the struggling coal industry, with Trump famously billing himself as “the last shot for miners.” But as the coal industry continues its slide, even Republican lawmakers are acknowledging a need for alternatives.
“There are other factors other than the administration in the White House that controls this. There are banks that are reluctant at this point to give loans for coal-fired furnaces,” said Republican state Sen. Danny Carroll, who sponsored the bill. “You look at the jobs that were lost, you look at the production of coal and how that has declined, we’ve got to learn lessons from that and we’ve got to have a third option.”
Kentucky’s coal industry has
been steadily declining for decades. Coal mining employment has fallen from 31,000 in 1990 to just over 6,300 today. Just three years ago, coal-fired power plants provided 93 percent of the state’s electricity. Today, that has fallen to 83 percent, according to the Kentucky Coal Association, as older plants are being shut down and replaced by natural gas.
Kentucky is one of 15 states that restrict the construction of new nuclear power facilities according to the National Conference of State Legislatures. Wisconsin lifted its ban last year. Nationwide, there are 61 nuclear power plants with 99 nuclear reactors in 30 states, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration.
The Tennessee Valley Authority, which supplies electricity to nearly half of Kentucky, operates seven nuclear reactors in Tennessee and Alabama. The federal utility has no plans to build any more reactors like what it built at its Browns Ferry, Sequoyah and Watts Bar nuclear plants. But TVA has entered into a memorandum of understanding to study the possibility of building small modular reactors in Oak Ridge to test out the new nuclear technology.
If successful, TVA could consider building such smaller reactors across its seven-state region as older coal and nuclear power plants are retired.
From its peak of 59 coal-fired units, TVA has already shuttered 18 coal units, including one at the Paradise coal plant in Kentucky.
The bill adopted in the Kentucky House Wednesday to open up the state for nuclear power has been pushed by local government and business leaders in the western part of the state, which was home to one of the few uranium enrichment plants in the country before it closed in 2013 in Paducah. That left the area teeming with a skilled workforce with no hope of employment in their field.
“Without that moratorium lifted, we absolutely have no opportunity,” said Bob Leeper, the judge executive for McCracken County and a former state senator who has pushed to lift the moratorium for years.
But Kentucky has been burned by the nuclear industry in the past. In the 1960s, seeking to lure the emerging nuclear energy industry into the state, Kentucky set up a place to store toxic waste. From 1963 to 1977, more than 800 corporations dumped 4.7 million cubic feet of radioactive waste at the site, but no nuclear reactor was ever built. The Maxey Flats site is closed, but its contaminated soil, surface water and groundwater resulted in an expensive state and federal cleanup.
“This is the Faustian bargain we engage in. We get cheap energy, but we saddle future generations with millennia responsibility of being mature enough to properly manage waste we are generating,” said Tom Fitzgerald, executive director of the Kentucky Resources Council, which has opposed lifting the moratorium.
Even if the ban is lifted, a nuclear power plant could still take more than 10 years to develop given the rigorous permitting process. And construction would be expensive, which would threaten to drive up electricity rates to pay for it. That is of particular concern to the state’s manufacturing sector, which uses large amounts of electricity in their production processes.
The bill requires state officials to review the state’s permitting process to ensure costs and “environmental consequences” are taken into account. That was enough for Fitzgerald to be “neutral” on the bill.
The Kentucky Coal Association is also neutral, although president Tyler White said they were not happy with the bill.
“We think there are more realistic policies that we should be pursuing in Frankfort than nuclear,” he said.