Chattanooga Times Free Press

SURPRISE! BLACK’S PORNOGRAPH­Y REMARKS TAKEN OUT OF CONTEXT

-

Tennessee gubernator­ial candidate Rep. Diane Black made news across the country the other day. You may have heard about it.

Among the headlines:

› Republican Diane Black of Tennessee says porn causes school shootings

› Rep. Diane Black of Tennessee says pornograph­y is a “root cause” of school shootings

› Tennessee lawmaker says pornograph­y is “root cause” of school shootings

› Lawmaker blames porn for school shootings

› TN lawmaker: Pornograph­y the “root cause” of school shootings

The only problem is Black, speaking during a listening session with pastors last week, never made a direct link between pornograph­y and school shootings.

The audio is available, but even news sites that provided a link to the audio took her remarks out of context. She did mention school shootings and she did mention pornograph­y, but her remarks centered on the “deteriorat­ion of the family.”

When children “don’t have that good support system,” Black said, they start “looking for something.”

They look for “something maybe on the internet,” she said, “maybe with a small group of friends, and they’re going in the wrong direction.”

Black went on to excoriate violent movies and stated she couldn’t watch such movies with her husband or grandchild­ren because she was not desensitiz­ed to them.

Then she turned to pornograph­y and instead of making the obvious point about the proliferat­ion and availabili­ty of online filth, she described a picture of 1980s America when pornograph­y began to make further inroads on VHS tapes.

“Pornograph­y — it’s available,” Black said. “It’s available on the shelf when you walk in the grocery store. Yeah, you have to reach up to get it, but there’s pornograph­y there.”

The Gallatin Republican then went back to speaking generally but uttered the words that caused news outlets to take her words out of context.

“All of this,” Black said, referring to the variety of internet content, violent movies and grocery-store VHS pornograph­y, “is available without parental guidance, and I think that is a big part of the root cause.”

In other words, the deteriorat­ion of the family — inherent in the lack of parental guidance, displayed in allowing children unlimited and unchecked internet viewing, which includes pornograph­y — is a root cause of school shootings.

Black is absolutely right. The number of mass shootings where the perpetrato­r came from a traditiona­l home, with a father and a mother, and grew up with what used to be honored as traditiona­l values, is minuscule, if it exists at all.

But “deteriorat­ion of the family,” however documented as a factor in behavior, social developmen­t, education, crime and lack of success in life, is not sexy, is so yesterday and won’t make headlines. But linking school shooting and pornograph­y, even if the headlines imply that pornograph­y is no more dangerous than video clips of kittens and ducklings? That’ll hunt.

Black followed her words about “all of this” by echoing a call many on the left and right have made that “mental illness is something we ought to address,” and she added that “we’ve got to address family.”

None of that made the sensationa­lized stories, though. If we said we were surprised by what was done to Black, we’d be lying. The words of Republican­s are frequently taken out of context and twisted to mean something else.

The media visit such on President Trump with impunity, but he’s also his own worst enemy with his tweets, his superlativ­e phrases and his off-the-cuff remarks.

The president, for instance, recently used the phrase “animals” to describe the terroristi­c MS-13 group, but many news outlets intentiona­lly claimed he was referring to illegal immigrants, causing unnecessar­y scorn to be heaped on him.

U.S. Rep. Marsha Blackburn, R-Tenn., also knows how words can get changed. Twitter initially took down a campaign video last October in which she mentioned fighting “the sale of baby body parts,” calling it inflammato­ry, but eventually restored it.

In general, we have our policy difference­s with Black, but neither she nor any other candidate deserves to have their words taken out of context. Such actions are especially dishearten­ing when the breakdown of the family — her actual point — is so critical in being the cause of so many of the woes visited on the country and the world today.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States