How to best aid immigrant children — and avoid scams
Q. MY FAMILY WISHES TO DONATE MONEY ASSISTING FAMILIES BEING IMPACTED BY THE IMMIGRANT CHILDREN SEPARATION. IS THERE ADVICE BBB MAY PROVIDE ON THIS ISSUE?
A. In response to public concerns about immigrant children and adults being detained in compounds near the Mexico/Texas border or transported to other locations, many people are seeking ways to help in any way possible. Sadly, and be advised, scammers often take advantage of these moments of vulnerability to deceive donors. In addition, there are often campaigns set up by well-meaning individuals who may not be able to carry out their promised activities.
BBB Wise Giving Alliance urges donors to give thoughtfully and avoid those seeking to take advantage of the generosity of others. Here are BBB WGA’s tips for trusted giving:
1. THOUGHTFUL GIVING
Take the time to check out the charity to avoid wasting your generosity by donating to a questionable or poorly managed effort. The first request for a donation may not be the best choice. Be proactive and find trusted charities that are providing assistance. Visit Give.org to verify if a charity meets the BBB Standards for Charitable Accountability.
2. CROWDFUNDING
While some crowdfunding sites have taken significant measures to help prevent fraudulent postings, other crowdfunding sites do very little vetting of individuals who decide to post for assistance after a tragedy. As a result, it is often difficult for donors to verify the trustworthiness of crowdfunding requests for support. For more Give.org tips on crowdfunding, check out this at www.give.org/news.
3. GETTING PERMISSION TO USE CHARITY NAMES
Individuals who decide to raise funds on behalf of an organization addressing immigrant issues should get permission from the subject charity before doing so.
4. BE CAUTIOUS ABOUT IN-KIND FUNDRAISING
Some individuals or organizations may raise funds to distribute in-kind assistance (such as clothing, televisions, toys, etc.) to immigrants in detention centers. Unless advance arrangements have been made to provide access for such distributions, solicitors may not be able to fulfill such well-intended promises.
5. GOVERNMENT REGISTRATION
About 40 of the 50 states in the U.S. require charities to register with a state government agency (usually a division of the state attorney general’s office) before they solicit for charitable gifts. If the charity is not registered, that may be a significant red flag. In Canada, all charitable organizations must be registered with the Canada Revenue Agency. If an organization is claiming to be a charity and isn’t registered with the CRA, that’s a red flag.
6. HOW WILL DONATIONS BE USED?
Watch out for vague appeals that don’t identify the intended use of funds. For example, how will the donations help immigrant children and their families? Also, unless told otherwise, donors will assume that funds collected quickly in the wake of a tragedy will be spent just as quickly. See if the appeal identifies when the collected funds will be used.
7. ADVOCACY ORGANIZATIONS
The immigration issues can generate requests from a variety of advocacy organizations on both sides of the political aisle. Donors can support those efforts as well, but note that some of those advocacy groups are not tax exempt as charities. Also, watch out for newly created advocacy groups that will be difficult to check out.
8. ONLINE CAUTION
Never click on links to charities on unfamiliar websites or in text messages or email. They may take you to a lookalike website where you will be asked to provide personal financial information, or may download harmful malware onto your computer. Don’t assume that charity recommendations on social media have already been vetted.
9. FINANCIAL TRANSPARENCY
After funds are quickly raised in reaction to public concern, it is even more important for organizations to provide an accounting of how funds were spent. Transparent organizations will post that information on their websites so that anyone can find out without having to wait until the audited financial statements are available sometime in the future.
10. NEWLY CREATED V. ESTABLISHED ORGANIZATIONS This is a personal giving choice, but an established charity will more likely have the experience to quickly address the circumstances and have a track record that can be evaluated. A newly formed organization may be well-meaning but will be difficult to check out and may not be well managed.
11. TAX DEDUCTIBILITY Not all organizations collecting funds in the U.S. to address immigration issues are tax exempt as charities under section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. Donors can support those other entities, but keep this in mind if they want to take a deduction for federal income tax purposes. You can check a U.S. organization’s tax status at www.irs.gov.
Jim Winsett is president of the Better Business Bureau in Chattanooga