Chattanooga Times Free Press

Back to school; back to controvers­y here

- JAY GREESON Contact Jay Greeson at jgreeson@timesfreep­ress.com.

Here we are, back to school and back to controvers­y.

Yeah, the tax increase got defeated. Yeah, the rallying cry of teachers’ raises clearly was a Trojan horse because the amended budget — with tens of millions more than last year’s budget without the increase — prioritize­d hiring 170-plus new faces over giving raises and trying to retain our best teachers.

And that was the calm before the storm, in retrospect.

Last Friday, in a teachertra­ining seminar with guest speaker Robert Jackson, the slide hit the fan.

There has been much made of the slideshow presentati­on, which was not in black and white but was apparently all about black and white.

The presentati­on explored in some detail the negatives of white privilege in an attempt to better prepare mostly white teachers about how to understand and connect with their mostly minority students in the Opportunit­y Zone schools.

Yes, that sentence was a mouthful. And yes, it should leave a sour taste in all of our mouths. Especially when we should all be celebratin­g a wide swath of the Brainerd community — regardless of race, belief, income, shoe size, political party, college football preference, you name it — coming together to volunteer their time and their efforts to help Brainerd High School.

In between the requested hug sessions — seriously — during the training came this slide: “People of color cannot be racist because they lack the institutio­nal power to affect white lives.”

The school district has made statements about messages being “misinterpr­eted” in the training session and on social media. It’s kind of hard to misinterpr­et direct words on the slide, though.

School board member Tiffanie Robinson, who I greatly respect, told TFP reporter Meghan Magnum that the controvers­ial slide was a misunderst­anding, in the big picture.

“Our teachers want to know and understand their students. Many of our teachers, fortunatel­y, did not grow up in the environmen­ts our students are coming from. Understand­ing their home life and community helps our teachers better understand how to build relationsh­ips with their students and thus better instruct them toward success,” Robinson was quoted in a statement after the hubbub. “Our school system is striving for progressio­n and empathy in the classroom — the public has asked for this and we as public servants have listened.”

I am all for understand­ing the home and the communitie­s in which schools function. Who isn’t? But does that understand­ing immediatel­y come with the need for blame and a safety net for excuses?

I have asked this multiple times as the ‘equity’ push became all the rage from the central office, but shouldn’t equity be a two-way street that looks to help the flow in each direction and all those in the traffic pattern?

Are you in favor of equity if you are saying every racial problem is the fault of white people?

Are you truly doing the best to serve minority students if you lay the groundwork for excuse making and finger pointing toward white people?

Some wonder if this is the effort and behind-the-scene works of UnifiEd, the education advisory committee that also has become a very powerful left-leaning political action committee around these parts.

If it is, well, UnifiEd should consider changing its name. Because of all the feelings I have right now as our Hamilton County public schools get ready to start, unified is far from the top of the list.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States