Shooting rekindles debate over definition of terrorism
Texas authorities said Monday that it is not investigating the Sutherland Springs, Texas, church shooting as terrorism after more than two dozen were killed Sunday.
But the New York City truck attack that killed eight people just a few days earlier was called an act of terror almost immediately. Why the difference?
❚ The FBI defines domestic terrorism as “perpetrated by individuals and/ or groups inspired by or associated with primarily U. S.- based movements that espouse extremist ideologies of a political, religious, social, racial or environmental nature.”
❚ Title 22 of the U. S. Code defines terrorism as “premeditated, politically motivated violence perpetrated against non- combatant targets by subnational groups or clandestine agents.”
❚ Merriam- Webster defines terrorism as the “systematic use of terror especially as a means of coercion.”
These definitions of terrorism require that death and violence are not the only aim, but that there also be a political or ideological motive.
“Where a lot of scholars tend to agree is that it’s some sort of politically motivated violence against non- combatants with the intention of causing societal fear,” said Fait Muedini, international studies professor at ButlerUniversity in Indianapolis.
In the case of the NYC attack, the suspect left a note pledging allegiance to the Islamic State, police said; federal prosecutors said he planned the attack for a year as he drifted into a violent radical ideology.
Though the motive is not precisely known in the First Baptist Church shooting, the gunman had a history of domestic abuse against his wife and child, and his mother- in- lawattended the church.
However, in both cases, many on social media focused on the race and religion of the suspects.
It was yet another example of how “terrorism” is no longer simply a legal definition, but an increasingly politicized one.
“Many people don’t understand the nuances of the definition of terrorism, and ever since 9/ 11 ... it’s been highly politicized,” Muedini said.
It happens on both sides — for instance, people on the left politicizing events as it pertains to gun control, and those on the right pushing “antiimmigrant positions, Islamophobia,” Muedini said.
President Trump, for instance, proposed changes to immigrant vetting and visas within hours of theNew York attack but hasn’t suggested any government response to the Las Vegas shooting that killed 58 ( in which Stephen Paddock’s motive remains under investigation).
President Obama also used the word “terrorism” to describe some mass casualty events that happened during his administration, such as the Pulse nightclub shooting in Orlando.
On the other side are those asking why the Texas church shooting has not been labeled a hate crime.
Targeting a group of people for their religious beliefs would likely meet the definition, but the Texas attack “wasn’t over religious beliefs,” TexasDepartment of Public Safety official Freeman Martin said.