Smoke detector mandate passed by Zoning Committee over Fire Dept. objections
Chicago’s oldest residential buildings would have until 2023 to install smoke detectors with 10-year batteries under a costly fire safety mandate advanced Monday over the objections of the Chicago Fire Department.
Fire Commissioner Richard Ford II and Public Safety Committee chairman Chris Taliaferro (29th) are dead-set against the idea — and sounded the alarm during a recent closed-door meeting with Mayor Lori Lightfoot’s Office of Legislative and Governmental Affairs.
They’re concerned about the added cost to homeowners already absorbing a punishing parade of property tax increases.
On Monday, Ald. Gilbert Villegas (36th), the mayor’s City Council floor leader, ignored those objections, persuading his Zoning Committee colleagues to approve his ordinance on a 9-to-3 vote.
Aldermen Anthony Beale (9th) and David Moore (17th) tried and failed to delay the vote, citing the CFD’s absence and opposition. When the delay failed, they voted no. So did Ald. Ray Lopez (15th).
“The Chicago Fire Department is not in support of this ordinance . ... We have to take the lead … from the Chicago Fire Department, [which] is in the business of saving lives,” said Beale, who later told colleagues CFD “knew nothing about” Monday’s vote.
Beale argued the new mandate threatens to undermine years of public education campaigns and free smoke detector distribution by CFD.
“There’s a reason why we say, ‘Daylight savings time, check your batteries.’ Now, we’re gonna say, ‘Don’t check it for 10 years.’ Now you’re asking seniors to remember ten years down the road to change or check their batteries when we have put years embedded in” a public education campaign, Beale said.
“That’s one of the reason why I’m opposed to it. Number two is the undue financial burden on seniors. Now, we’re about to add another on to them and they can’t afford their prescription drugs. They can’t afford their groceries. … And now, we’re gonna ask them to pay a little bit more for a smoke detector. That’s just unrealistic at this time.”
Villegas countered: “Take into account the cost to change the battery every two years, the labor to go do it. When you add that up, it’s cheaper to do the 10-year battery.”
Buildings Commissioner Judy Frydland sided with Villegas. She argued the city was “not abolishing” existing smoke detectors that normally use a nine-volt battery, which can be removed during cooking; the 10-year batteries can’t be removed.
In fact, the Chicago Fire Department will pass out the old versions until Jan. 1, 2023, when the mandate takes effect.
But once those smoke detectors expire, the owners of buildings “erected or converted to residential use before June 1, 1984” must install what she called “much safer” smoke detectors with the 10-year batteries.
“If you put in a new home smoke detector in December 2022, you can keep it until 2032. And when it’s time to upgrade, you install a 10-year battery. It’s not a matter of re-wiring,” Frydland said.
“This is not yanking out every smoke detector in everybody’s home. It’s a very gradual way to go to the new technology.”
Chicago Fire Department spokesman Larry Langford could not be reached for comment on Monday’s vote.
Last month, Langford told the SunTimes forcing all Chicago homes to switch to smoke detectors with 10-year batteries would mean “a net loss of protected homes.”
“The cheapest standard detector is $5. The cheapest 10-year we find is $15. While it’s true that, in the long run, it’s cheaper to operate, most people make the purchase based on what they can spend now,” Langford wrote in a text message to the Sun-Times.