BATTLE OF THE BOOKSELLERS
Evanston bookstore owner sues Amazon over alleged price-fixing scheme that makes it impossible for retailers to compete
An Evanston bookstore owner wants to take on Amazon.
Nina Barrett, owner of Bookends and Beginnings, signed on as the named plaintiff in a class-action lawsuit filed last week that accuses Amazon of orchestrating a pricefixing scheme with the nation’s leading book publishers that makes it impossible for other retailers to beat their prices.
According to the suit, contracts that Amazon has with the nation’s “Big Five” publishers — Penguin Random House, HarperCollins, Hachette, Macmillan and Simon & Schuster — block the publishers from giving other retailers better prices.
“I, along with most independent bookstore owners in America, feel incredibly frustrated because we’ve seen that the playing field is not level,” Barrett told the Sun-Times. “We have to talk to our customers all the time about why we can’t match Amazon’s pricing.”
Amazon didn’t return a message seeking comment.
The suit, which was filed in New York, seeks to include all booksellers that bought books from the Big Five after March 25, 2017. It seeks damages and an injunction on the “anti-competitive” practice.
“It’s been very frustrating to watch the growth of Amazon and think, ‘Me, just little old me by myself, I can’t stop this, but I can see that it’s unfair,’ ” Barrett said.
Two law firms with experience in fighting big tech — Sperling and Slater in Chicago and Hagens Berman in Seattle — teamed up on the case, and when it came time to find someone to represent book purchasers, Barrett was the perfect match.
Attorney Eamon Kelly, who lives in Evanston and regularly shops for biographies at Barrett’s store, pitched Barrett to his fellow attorneys and then pitched Barrett, who said she “jumped on the idea.”
Barrett’s shop, with its alleyway entrance, is “a magical place to look at books,” Kelly said. Barrett, 60, opened her bookstore in 2014. The financial pain felt by her bookstore due to Amazon’s pricing is real, Barrett said, and would have been more acute during the pandemic if not for an online fundraising campaign that raised nearly $50,000, money her business received through the Paycheck Protection Program and the fact that a Barnes and Noble about a block from her store closed last year, funneling more customers her way.
She called Amazon a “juggernaut” and a “bully.”
“We think that being a place matters, that the browsing experience matters,” she said.
“We get up and battle and fight every day to make our business model work, and we do it out of passion. But no one of us would ever have the power to be able to take on Amazon,” she said.