Sheriff’s plan for boardwalk criticized as being political
In a move some criticized as exploiting the homelessness crisis for political gain, Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva sent deputies Tuesday to Venice’s boardwalk to begin to fulfill his pledge to clear the area of homeless encampments by July 4.
Villanueva’s move is unusual since the Los Angeles Police Department has law enforcement jurisdiction over Venice, not the sheriff’s department. Police Chief Michel Moore said he was aware of the sheriff’s efforts in the area and that the two spoke several weeks ago, prior to Villanueva’s first visit to the boardwalk on May 26.
Over the next few weeks, Villanueva plans to use deputies with the department’s Homeless Outreach Services Team to offer resources, including vouchers for temporary shelters through Project Roomkey, to unhoused people living along the Venice boardwalk, the sheriff’s office said.
The department plans to use enforcement, such as arrests, for those who choose not to take the resources offered and decide to remain at the oceanfront area, Moore said, recalling details from his conversation with Villanueva.
Advocates for the homeless believe the plan mirrors efforts by the city and Los Angeles Police Department that led to the removal of unhoused people living in Echo Park Lake in March, which drew major protests.
Homeless outreach deputies walked throughout the boardwalk Tuesday at the beginning of the removal plan. The sheriff’s department said it will send deputies there again today.
During a press conference Tuesday, Moore acknowledged the outreach work Los Angeles Councilman Mike Bonin, city workers and community partners have been offering to unhoused residents over the past few weeks. In that span, the number of unhoused residents living on the Venice boardwalk has gone from 240 to 130, Moore said.
Bonin, whose district includes Venice, said he doesn’t welcome Villanueva’s plan to remove the homeless population from the area, calling into question his motivations for the effort.
“Villanueva hasn’t offered actual help,” Bonin said in a statement posted to Twitter. “This is a serious crisis. We need people interested in solving it, not exploiting it.”
He added that the sheriff is exploiting Venice to further the idea “that crime and homelessness are caused by progressives and that the only fix is tougher laws, longer sentences and more prisons,” which Bonin called a “nefarious lie.”
Peggy Kennedy, a homeless advocate with The Venice Justice Committee and L.A. Street Watch, said Villanueva is using the situation and capitalizing off anti-homeless bias from some in the Venice community with his reelection in 2022 in mind.
Kennedy, whose group offers legal aid to homeless individuals in Venice, said using law enforcement adds unnecessary pressure and coercion to those living on the streets.
“How is accepting services appropriate when you are offering them under the color of the law with armed officers?” Kennedy said.
Villanueva visited the boardwalk in late May and again on Monday, this time surrounded by cameras, saying he wants to understand the homelessness crisis facing the Los Angeles beach community and that he hopes to correct what city leaders have failed to do.
Also on Monday, Los Angeles City Councilman Joe Buscaino, who is also a mayoral candidate, visited the Venice boardwalk, using the community’s unhoused population as a backdrop for unveiling his plan to address homelessness. His plan also met criticism from homeless advocates due to Buscaino’s reliance on law enforcement and his prior anti-homeless rhetoric.
Throughout the pandemic, Los Angeles has put a moratorium on the ban on daytime camping in public areas. The moratorium is based on CDC guidelines to prevent the spread of COVID-19 and has limited the role LAPD officers have played in forcing people out of encampments such as the one that has formed in Venice.
However, Moore said he hopes the Los Angeles City Council will lift the moratorium as COVID-19 transmissions rates have decreased in the county and as businesses begin to reopen. He wants his officers to again pick up enforcement on the camping ban.