Daily Local News (West Chester, PA)

Kane will not defend NRA-backed law

Legislatio­n allows ‘member organizati­ons’ to sue municipali­ties with firearms regulation­s that are stricter than PA’s

- By MARC LEVY

HARRISBURG » Pennsylvan­ia Attorney General Kathleen Kane is leaving it to the governor’s office to defend a lawsuit challengin­g a National Rifle Associatio­n-backed law that was designed to dismantle illegal municipal firearms ordinances, officials said Friday. the case.

Corbett, a Republican who opposes new forms of gun control, signed the law last month. The law widens the ability of the NRA or gun owners to successful­ly sue over municipal firearms ordinances.

A spokesman for Gov. Tom Corbett said the governor’s legal office will defend the law against the challenge led by Philadelph­ia, Pittsburgh and Lancaster. Kane’s office sent word earlier in the week that she would not take

“We can find no legitimate reason for the attorney general to decline to defend the commonweal­th in this case,” said Corbett’s spokesman, Jay Pagni.

The law takes effect in the coming weeks, and opponents fear it will unleash a wave of expensive lawsuits against dozens of cities and towns that have sought to curb gun violence but bumped up against a Legislatur­e that has resisted new gun control measures.

However, Corbett leaves office Jan. 20 after losing last month’s election, and he will be replaced by Democrat Tom Wolf, who has said he opposes the law. On Friday, a spokesman would only say that Wolf will review all existing litigation once he takes office.

Kane’s office said it was more efficient and in the best interest of Pennsylvan­ia for the governor’s lawyers to defend the law. Last year, Kane, a Democrat, refused to defend Pennsylvan­ia’s law banning the recognitio­n of same-sex marriage against a federal lawsuit. Corbett’s office unsuccessf­ully defended the law, and it was struck down in May.

In general, Pennsylvan­ia bars its municipali­ties from enforcing firearms ordinances that are stronger than state law. But the NRA has complained that dozens of local ordinances go unchalleng­ed in Pennsylvan­ia courts by residents who can prove they harmed them.

Under the new law, gun owners would no longer have to prove they had been harmed by the law to successful­ly challenge it, and “membership organizati­ons” could stand in to sue on behalf of any Pennsylvan­ia member. The challenger also could seek damages.

Pennsylvan­ia’s Republican-controlled House and Senate each passed the bill over the protests of most urban Democrats and some suburban Republican­s.

Both the NRA and the gun control advocacy group Cease-Fire-PA said they knew of no similar law in any other state.

The lawsuit, filed Nov. 10, does not challenge the aim of the law. Rather, it argues that lawmakers approved the measure in violation of state constituti­onal provisions designed to promote transparen­cy in the legislativ­e process.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States