Daily Local News (West Chester, PA)

While Trump feasts, troops on the border eat rations

- Dana Milbank Columnist

President Trump is reportedly planning to celebrate Thanksgivi­ng once again at his members-only Mar-aLago Club in Florida, feasting on (if previous menus repeat) a 24-dish extravagan­za of turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, marshmallo­w sweet potatoes, red snapper, leg of lamb, grilled diver scallops, stone crab, ahi tuna martinis, Maine lobster bisque, short ribs, beef tenderloin and seven desserts.

It will likely all be topped off by what the president calls “the most beautiful piece of chocolate cake” — available exclusivel­y to members ($200,000 initiation fee) and guests.

Things will be rather less sumptuous along the southern border, to which Trump, just before the midterm elections, ordered some 5,600 troops, with another 1,400 on the way, to contain the “national emergency” posed by the approachin­g caravan of Central American families seeking asylum.

Since the election, Trump has forgotten about the mortal peril posed by the caravan “invasion” — he has mentioned the “caravan” only once, and only when asked — but the troops he ordered to act in this political advertisem­ent can’t forget. They will remain on the border through Thanksgivi­ng, the New York Times reported, eating MRE rations, living in tents without electricit­y, receiving neither combat pay nor hostilefir­e pay.

Their only task is to spend a few days stringing barbed wire. After this, their mission, Defense Secretary Jim Mattis said, “is somewhat to be determined.”

This is the time when another president would pay a Thanksgivi­ng visit to the troops he has mobilized. President George W. Bush famously visited Iraq on Thanksgivi­ng in 2003.

Trump, similarly, could visit his underemplo­yed troops and give them a sense of mission — even a phony one.

Mattis tried another way to give meaning to the troops’ aimless mission on the border. “I would put this in a little historic context,” he told reporters last Wednesday. “I think many of you are aware that President Wilson 100 years ago, a little over 100 years ago, deployed the U.S. Army to the southwest border . ... The threat then was Pancho Villa’s troops, a revolution­ary raiding across the border into the United States.”

At first glance, it would appear that a raid by Pancho Villa’s guerrillas that killed 17 Americans in New Mexico 102 years ago has very little to do with the unarmed and impoverish­ed Central Americans currently seeking refuge in the United States.

But maybe Mattis has revealed something about Trump’s national-security decisions. The policies may be inappropri­ate for the current day, but they would have been eminently sensible a century ago, or earlier.

Some might think Trump’s “travel ban” is an attempt to punish Muslim countries on the basis of religion. But there is historical context! Between 1801 and 1815, we fought in the Barbary Wars against what is now Libya — one of the countries targeted by the travel ban.

Some might take issue with Trump’s attempt to portray Mexicans as murderers. But there is historical context! Remember the Alamo? The Mexican-American War? The Cortinista Bandits of 1859? The Las Cuevas War of 1875? Anyone?

There is even historical context for Trump spending Thanksgivi­ng in Mar-a-Lago’s luxury rather than roughing it with troops along the border. That area was highly unstable in 1521, when Europeans defeated the Aztecs and their emperor, Montezuma II.

We can’t risk sending the president there. You never know when Montezuma might exact his revenge.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States