Don’t give him a pass
Rodgers deserves scrutiny over ‘immunized’ claim
There are some potentially serious problems with the “unvaccinated-Aaron Rodgers-has-COVID-19” story, so let’s get the funny business out of the way first.
When reporters asked the Packers quarterback back in August whether he’d been vaccinated, he replied, “Yeah, I’ve been immunized.”
Not exactly. Rodgers may have won “Celebrity Jeopardy!” a half-dozen years ago, but he’s no more a medical doctor than Julius Erving was. Otherwise, he would have known better.
So be charitable and give Rodgers the benefit of the doubt. Assume he really believed whatever cockamamie home remedy some friend whipped up afforded him the same immunity against the virus as the vaccine.
But that’s not what he said. And what he said next sure made it sound that by “immunized” Rodgers meant he’d gotten the jab.
“There’s guys on the team that haven’t been vaccinated. I think it’s a personal decision,” he added. “I’m not going to judge those guys.”
That helps explain why most people were surprised by reports Wednesday that Rodgers tested positive, which can happen to anyone, but even more surprised to learn he wasn’t vaccinated. Raise your hand if you were surprised to find out Packers coach Matt LaFleur wasn’t one of them.
LaFleur deftly sidestepped a question Wednesday about whether Rodgers’ “immunization” remark from August was misleading, saying, “It’s a great question for Aaron.”
The third-year coach also refused to confirm Rodgers’ positive test result or his vaccination status, but did acknowledge his star player was in the NFL’s COVID-19 protocol, which mandates 10 days away from the team.
Rodgers will miss Sunday’s game against the Chiefs, but the Packers are 7-1 with a 3 ½-game lead in their division. Plus, Jordan Love, his backup and the Packers’ first-round draft pick in 2020, gets the chance to gain some much-needed seasoning, and if all goes well, Rodgers will be back in time for the week after against the Seahawks. So what’s the big deal?
That could depend on what the Packers know and when they knew it.
According to reports, Rodgers requested an exemption from the COVID protocol this summer based on his antibody levels, and was denied after an infectious disease specialist appointed by the league and the players’ union found no proof of protection against the virus. Technically, then, he was unvaccinated and thus subject to some tough restrictions.
Those range from daily testing to mask-wearing to a potential five-day quarantine just for crossing paths with someone who tests positive and Rodgers, as anyone who checks sports and entertainment websites even occasionally knows, gets around.
Last week, two of his receivers — All-Pro Davante Adams and Allen Lazard — and Packers defensive coordinator Joe Barry were in the protocol and missed the win over the Cardinals.
On Tuesday, third-string quarterback Kurt Benkert went on the COVID-19 reserve list. A day later, cornerback Isaac Yiadom joined Rodgers’ on the stay-home-from-work list for Week 9.
“I watch what these guys do,” LaFleur said, insisting the club has followed the league’s guidelines throughout. “I can only speak to our football space, but yeah, absolutely . ... I think our guys do an outstanding job.”
Maybe, but NFL officials said they planned to look for themselves. League rules allow vaccinated players who test positive to return after two negative tests taken at least 24 hours apart; unvaccinated players testing positive must isolate for at least 10 days.
“The primary responsibility for enforcement of the COVID protocols within club facilities rests with each club,” NFL spokesman Brian McCarthy said in a statement. “Failure to properly enforce the protocols has resulted in discipline being assessed against clubs in the past. The league is aware of the situation in Green Bay and will be reviewing with the Packers.”
The big sports in general, and the NFL in particular, have done a very good job of managing the pandemic, largely by adopting strict guidelines and refusing to wink or nod whenever somebody refuses to play by the rules. That’s why Kyrie Irving is watching Nets games from his couch instead of a basketball court, and why Nick Rolovich, after just 11 games in charge, became the ex-head coach at Washington State less than a month ago.
Neither was vaccinated, but they didn’t claim to be “immunized,” either. Whether that’s a distinction without a difference remains to be seen.