Dakotas lead US in virus growth as masks debated
Cases spurred by schools reopening, motorcycle rally
SIOUX FALLS, S.D. — Coronavirus infections in the Dakotas are growing faster than anywhere else in the nation, fueling impassioned debates over masks and personal freedom after months in which the two states avoided the worst of the pandemic.
Theargumentovermasks raged last week in Brookings, South Dakota, as the city council considered requiring face coverings in businesses. The city was forcedtomoveitsmeetingto a local arena to accommodate intense interest, with many citizens speaking against it, before the requirement ultimately passed.
North Dakota and South Dakota lead the country in new cases per capita over the last two weeks, ranking first and second respectively, according to Johns Hopkins University.
South Dakota has also posted some of the country’s highest positivity rates for COVID-19 tests in the last week — over 17% — an indication there are more infections than tests are catching.
Infections have been spurred by schools and universities reopening and mass gatherings like the Sturgis Motorcycle Rally, which drew hundreds of thousands of people from across the country.
The Republican governors of both states have eschewed mask requirements, tapping into a spirit of independence from enduring the winters and storms of the Great Plains.
The Dakotas were not always a hot spot. For months, the states appeared to avoid the worst of the pandemic, watching from afar as it raged through large cities. But spiking infection rates have fanned out across the nation, from the East Coast to the Sun Belt and nowinto the Midwest.
When the case count stayed lowduring the spring and early summer, people grew weary of constantly taking precautions, said Dr. Benjamin Aaker, president of the South Dakota State Medical Association.
“People have a tendency to become complacent,” he said. “Then they start to relax the things that they were doing properly, and that’s when the increase in cases starts to go up.”
Health officials point out that the COVID-19 case increases have been among younger groups that are not hospitalized at high rates. But infections have not been contained to college campuses.
“College studentswork in places where the vulnerable live, such as nursing homes,” saidDr. JoelWalz, theGrand Forks, North Dakota, city and county health officer. “Some of them are nursing studentswhoare doing rotations where they’re going to see people who are really at risk. Iworry about that.”
Over 1,000 students at the states’ four largest universities — the University of NorthDakota, NorthDakota State University, South Dakota State University and University of South Dakota — left campus to quarantine after being exposed to the virus, according to data released by the schools. The Sturgis rally also spread infections across the region, with health officials in 12 states reporting over 300 cases among people who attended the event.
But requiring masks has been controversial. In Brookings, opponents said they believed the mandate was a violation of civil liberties.
“There are a lot of things we have in life that we have to deal with that cause death,” business owner Teresa Holloman told the council.“We live inAmerica, and we have certain inalienable rights.”
Though Brookings passed its ban, another hot spot — North Dakota’sMorton County, just west of the capital of Bismarck — rejected a mask requirement after citizens spoke against it. Brookingsmaybe the lone municipality with such an order in theDakotas outside of Native American reservations, which have generally been more vigilant in adopt
ing coronavirus precautions. Native Americans have disproportionately died from COVID-19, accounting for 24% of deaths statewide.
North Dakota Gov. Doug Burgum and South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem have resisted mask requirements. Burgum promotes personal choice but tried to encourage masks with a social media campaign. Noem has discouraged mask requirements, saying she doubts a broad consensus in themedical community that they help prevent infections.
At a press briefing, Burgum displayed a slide that showed active cases in
neighboring Minnesota rising to record levels since implementing a mask mandate July 25.
“In the end, it’s about individual decisions, not what the government does,” he said.
Noem, who has yet to appear at a public event with amask, carved out a reputation as a staunch conservative when she defied calls early in the pandemic for lockdownorders.
The U.S. has more than 6.4 million confirmed coronavirus infections and over 193,000 deaths from COVID-19 according to JohnsHopkinsUniversity.