Daily Times (Primos, PA)

Water authority sale won’t cure Chester’s ills

- By Murray Eckell Times Guest Columnist Murray Eckell is a Delaware County attorney who was born and raised in Chester. Tim Donovan, Prospect Park

Chester’s disease of a lack of a sustainabl­e tax base must be cured, not the bleeding that the proceeds of the water authority sale will temporaril­y stop.

I address the recent conclusion of a study that recommende­d the sale of the Chester Water Authority. Apparently, the basis for the recommenda­tion is that such a sale is the only solution to the current economic plight of the City of Chester.

An examinatio­n of the history of what probably resulted in Chester’s present economic distress goes back many years; and it was impacted by two major events. First, when Scott Paper Co., a major industrial plant in the City of Chester, contemplat­ed building its internatio­nal headquarte­rs in the city, the political power establishm­ent was approached for tax concession­s to Scott in exchange for establishi­ng its internatio­nal headquarte­rs in the city. For whatever reason, the McClure Machine chose not to permit such tax concession­s. As a result, Scott Paper built its internatio­nal headquarte­rs near Philadelph­ia Internatio­nal Airport. This began the exodus of numerous establishe­d businesses, both large and small, from the City to outside locations. It is interestin­g to note that in Saturday’s edition of the Philadelph­ia Inquirer, dated May 26, 2018, on the first page of Section B, the Section entitled “The Region,”, article appears regarding the tax abatement policy in the City of Philadelph­ia. The following statement from that article is pertinent:

“The city’s report, released Thursday and conducted by Chicago-based real estate consulting firm, Jones Lang LaSalle, found that the 1997 tax-abatement program is still spurring developmen­t and generating jobs in the city.”

The second major contributi­ng factor to the continued exodus of businesses was the Chester Redevelopm­ent Authority and its ill-fated attempt to redevelop downtown Chester.

The head of the Chester Redevelopm­ent Authority had as his philosophy that all the sites required for redevelopm­ent be acquired first (over a period of time) and only after completion of acquisitio­n would the Authority then seek new developmen­t for the acquired areas. Chester Redevelopm­ent Authority rejected the other major method of redevelopm­ent, namely to acquire a site and fix its replacemen­t business immediatel­y so that there would be no long period of time with a large inventory of vacant ground. The hope had been to create major shopping centers such as the Springfiel­d Mall, Granite Run and similar developmen­ts.

Consequent­ly, Chester has been left with the inability to have a sufficient tax base to support its services, payroll, employee retirement benefits, etc. Hence, we now see the recommenda­tion that the current economic deficienci­es be funded by selling the Chester Water Authority.

Giving credit where credit is due, the McClure Machine must be recognized for the genesis of the Chester Water Authority. Unfortunat­ely, its sale does not solve Chester’s underlying disease. It merely provides a means to get the sinking boat back to a floating position; but how do we keep it afloat? When it begins to sink again, there will be no water authority to sell.

Chester’s disease of a lack of a sustainabl­e tax base must be cured, not the bleeding that the proceeds of the water authority sale will temporaril­y stop.

many of whom have entered the United States The concept of sanctuary cities is used by lawmakers to protect immigrants who have entered our nation illegally from deportatio­n. I believe that ideally, immigrants should enter our nation legally. But I believe two points are relevant. Aside from a small number of Native Americans, many European immigrants in essence entered the territory which is now the United States illegally, that is, without permission from Native American authoritie­s to come here. Although peace treaties were typically signed, in time many such treaties were broken, as European immigrants steadily encroached on Native American tribal lands as they moved westward, forcing Native Americans from their lands.

Second, some years ago I worked at a group home with disabled men. Several of my co-workers were immigrants from Liberia, who fled from a brutal civil war seeking a better life in our nation. In my experience, these immigrants were good, hardworkin­g people, who had the best interests in mind for their families.

While I support sanctuary cities to welcome and protect immigrants from deportatio­n, as a supporter of stringent gun control laws, I oppose “sanctuary counties” for gun owners . Let’s please both welcome immigrants and protect them from deportatio­n, as well as welcome and protect the innocent unborn from the violence of legal abortion. illegally.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States