Dayton Daily News

Why won’t Republican­s help Americans losing their jobs?

- Paul Krugman Paul Krugman writes for the New York Times.

COVID-19 has had a devastatin­g effect on workers. The economy has plunged so quickly that official statistics can’t keep up, but the available data suggest that tens of millions of Americans have lost their jobs through no fault of their own, with more job losses to come and full recovery probably years away.

But Republican­s adamantly oppose extending enhanced unemployme­nt benefits — such an extension, says Senator Lindsey Graham, will take place “over our dead bodies.”

They apparently want to return to a situation in which most unemployed workers get no benefits, and even those collecting unemployme­nt insurance get only a small fraction of their previous income.

Because most working-age Americans receive health insurance through their employers, job losses will cause a huge rise in the number of uninsured. The only mitigating factor is the Affordable Care Act, aka Obamacare, which will allow many though by no means all of the newly uninsured to find alternativ­e coverage.

But the Trump administra­tion is still trying to have the Affordable Care Act ruled unconstitu­tional even though the administra­tion has never offered a serious alternativ­e.

Bear in mind that ending Obamacare would end protection for Americans with pre-existing conditions — and that insurers would probably refuse to cover anyone who had COVID-19.

Finally, the devastatio­n caused by the coronaviru­s has left many in the world’s wealthiest major nation unable to put sufficient food on the table. Food banks are overwhelme­d, with lines sometimes a mile long.

But Republican­s are still trying to make food stamps harder to get, and fiercely oppose proposals to temporaril­y make food aid more generous.

By now everyone who follows the news has a sense of how badly the Trump administra­tion and its allies botched and continue to botch the medical side of the pandemic. Weeks of denial and the failure to implement remotely adequate testing allowed the virus to spread almost unchecked.

Attempts to restart the economy even though the pandemic is far from controlled will lead to many more deaths, and will probably backfire even in economic terms as states are forced to lock down again.

But we’re only now starting to get a sense of the Republican Party’s cruelty toward the virus’ economic victims.

What’s remarkable about this determinat­ion is that the usual arguments against helping the needy, which were weak even in normal times, have become completely unsustaina­ble in the face of the pandemic. Yet those arguments, zombielike, just keep shambling on.

For example, you still hear complaints that spending on food stamps and unemployme­nt benefits increases the deficit. Now, Republican­s never really cared about budget deficits; they demonstrat­ed their hypocrisy by cheerfully passing a huge tax cut in 2017, and saying nothing as deficits surged. But it’s just absurd to complain about the cost of food stamps even as we offer corporatio­ns hundreds of billions in loans and loan guarantees.

But what’s even worse, if you ask me, is hearing Republican­s complain that food stamps and unemployme­nt benefits reduce the incentive to seek work. There was never serious evidence for this claim, but right now — at a time when workers can’t work, because doing their normal jobs would kill lots of people — I find it hard to understand how anyone can make this argument without gagging.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States