Others say: Taliban still lurks
The conflict in Afghanistan remains a stalemate between beleaguered Afghan security forces and the Taliban, but momentum has shifted to the latter. Taliban militants now control or contest more than 40 percent of the country. In rural areas, the Taliban have rolled out shadow governments that tackle everything from land dispute mediation to crime-fighting. Afghan troop losses are so large that entire units are getting replenished.
Now completing the fourth month of his presidency, Donald Trump has done little with Afghanistan, apart from reveling in his use of an 11-ton bomb on an Islamic State tunnel network in the eastern part of the country. And there's no evidence that made any major dent in the militant group's presence there.
Trump's generals have urged him to sign off on sending more troops to Afghanistan.
We hope he listens to his generals. But Trump must also realize that more combat likely won't end this war. Afghanistan can only get peace through a negotiated settlement with the Taliban. The president's policy for Afghanistan, which he has yet to lay out, should have at its core a strategy for getting the Taliban to the negotiating table. Not an easy task, and one that requires three objectives:
• With guidance from U.S. and NATO troops, Afghan security forces not only need to halt the Taliban's momentum but to hurt the insurgency enough that Taliban leaders see merit in sitting down for peace talks. There's no incentive right now for them to talk.
• Pakistan has a long-standing relationship with the Afghan Taliban, and it can play a critical role in getting insurgent leaders to agree to talks. Taliban leaders have been able to survive for so long in part because Pakistan has always provided them secure refuge on its side of the Afghan border. Trump's policy in Afghanistan must include outreach to Pakistan, and he can get Islamabad's attention by tying future military aid to that country to its help brokering Taliban peace talks.
• Finally, Afghanistan's unity government has to start cleansing itself of corruption that taints society from top to bottom. Taliban shadow governments appeal to Afghans because the alternative is an Afghan government always on the take. Paying bribes remains the norm for any Afghan who wants a crime or civil dispute resolved.
Crafting a policy for Afghanistan may be one of the trickiest missions on Trump's foreign policy agenda. The task is vexing and precarious, especially for a new president--just ask Barack Obama, who in eight years failed to lay out for Afghans a clear path toward peace and prosperity.
It's a quagmire Trump inherited, but he owns it now. He should deploy the 3,000 troops, then drive three governments— Afghanistan's, Pakistan's and his own— toward negotiated peace.