Did Natalie really do it?
No, it wasn’t Natalie. She and Andie did have a fight earlier that week, and she did stay behind at the picnic area, leaving her alone with the food. But, it wasn’t her. It was actually the deer Andie and Sofia saw at the park during their last visit. The rustling leaves noises gave it away to Sofia. Plus, Sofia knew that the deer was hungry — she was trying to eat from the trash last time they saw her. Most of all she remembered that the deer was shy — she hid from people. So the girls decided to hide behind a tree, and after a few minutes, they saw the deer make an appearance, which proved Sofia’s theory.