Fiery campus speeches backed by bigger force
U.S. attorney general among alumni of conservative group hoping to expand
BUFFALO, N.Y. — “Let’s give it up for the racists that are hosting this event!” someone yelled, and the crowd roared, foot-stomping in unison, then breaking into song: Woody Guthrie’s “This Land Is Your Land.” One member of the audience held up a sign, “Queers Against Islamaphobia.” Another unfurled a banner: “Muslims Welcome. Fascists Get Out.”
Close to 200 students kept up the noise for more than an hour in a University at Buffalo lecture hall on May 1, mostly drowning out the evening’s featured speaker, Robert Spencer, a conservative author and blogger who espouses a dark view of Islam.
The event appeared to follow a familiar script, in which a large contingent of liberals muzzles a provocative speaker invited by a small conservative student club. But the propelling force behind the event — and a number of recent heat-seeking speeches on college campuses — was a national conservative group that is well funded, highly organized and on a mission, in its words, to “restore sanity at your school.”
The group, the Young America’s Foundation, had paid Spencer’s $2,000 fee, trained the student leader who organized the event and provided literature for distribution. Other than the possibility of outside interference, little had been left to chance.
The speeches are a part of the group’s mission of grooming future conservative leaders — Attorney General Jeff Sessions and Stephen Miller, a White House adviser, are among its alumni — and its long list of donors has included television game show host Pat Sajak, novelist Tom Clancy, billionaire brothers David H. and Charles G. Koch, and Amway billionaires Richard and Helen DeVos, who gave $10 million to endow the Reagan Ranch near Santa Barbara, Calif., which the foundation runs as a preserve. (Their daughter-inlaw, Betsy DeVos, the secretary of education, is not a donor, the group says.)
Over the past two years, armed with a $16 million infusion from the estate of an orthodontist in California, Robert Ruhe, the organization has doubled its programming, including campus speeches. In 2016 that meant 111 speakers on 77 campuses. On the group’s website, it boasted of “dispatching” 31 speakers to colleges last month alone.
In that time, the speakers have gotten edgier, more in-your-face and sometimes even meanspirited. Among them is Ann Coulter, whose canceled speech last month at the University of California, Berkeley, led the foundation, which was covering most of her $20,000 fee, to sue the college, arguing that it had violated the First Amendment in its failure to provide a suitable time and place for the event.
The resulting clashes on university campuses, including protests and efforts to block speeches, have raised free speech questions. And at Berkeley, even liberals who oppose Coulter’s viewpoints said her speech should have been allowed to proceed.
Small groups, big help
In the meantime, protesters have questioned whether such events are cynically intended to provoke reactions.
“It’s part of a larger systematic and extremely well-funded effort to disrupt public universities and create tension among student groups on campus,” said Alexandra Prince, a doctoral student at Buffalo who circulated a petition to block Spencer.
But Ron Robinson, who has served as Young America’s president for more than three decades, said the group’s goal is simply “to increase appreciation and support of conservative ideas, not to stir up leftists or Muslims.”
The foundation has more than 250 high school and college campus chapters, known as Young Americans for Freedom, which was originally a separate organization. One of that group’s founders was aristocratic publisher and television host William F. Buckley Jr., who reveled in poking fun at and holes in liberalism in higher education.
Students can attend training seminars at the group’s Reston, Va., headquarters — conveniently near a Washington Metro stop — as well as off-site conferences, including those held at a center in Santa Barbara, which is also open to the public as a museum.
The foundation teaches essentials such as when it is legal to record a conversation with a college administrator; how to press schools to cover some of the security costs; regulations on sidewalk chalking, fliers and other forms of promotion and whether they can be challenged; and when to call the foundation’s legal staff for help.
“Conservative students have to learn how to negotiate through their school’s bureaucracy, which is often put in place to prevent or control student events,” Robinson said in an email.
The group also provides kits of what it calls “conservative swag,” such as a giant poster of Ronald Reagan on horseback, instructions for staging a funeral for the death of Halloween (buy a lawn decoration coffin or make one yourself ) — a swipe at university efforts to discourage offensive costumes — and posters to distribute on Sept. 11 featuring vivid depictions of the World Trade Center attacks and terrorist beheadings.
In addition to its fiery speakers and marquee names like Newt Gingrich, the organization’s roster includes many low-fuss speakers like publisher Steve Forbes and author Ben Stein. It was not associated with the divisive campus appearances recently made by right-wing writer Milo Yiannopoulos.
But it does sponsor Spencer, whose writings, including on his website Jihad Watch, are full of dire warnings about the global threat of radical Islam. His work was cited repeatedly in the 1,500-page manifesto of Anders Behring Breivik, who killed 77 people in Norway in 2011.
‘Not an intellectual’
Spencer was invited to the University at Buffalo by a Young Americans for Freedom chapter organized in the past year. It was no match for a much larger Muslim Student Association, which organized a 1960s-style sit-in that began hours before Spencer arrived.
A small group of Young Americans for Freedom members gathered near the front, looking buttoned up in business attire and taking on expressions of disgust.
“It’s one of the most disrespectful displays I’ve seen in my life,” said one member, Patrick Weppner, a sophomore majoring in computer science.
When he was able to talk above the noise, Spencer cited excerpts from the Quran as evidence that the text is used as justification for violence.
During a Q&A session, Pasha Syed, an imam from a local mosque, cited a New Testament passage about killing one’s enemies. Spencer said the difference was that the Quran entreats followers to violence.
“Jihad is obligatory for everyone able to perform it, male and female, and it is definitely warfare that they are talking about,” Spencer said. An audience member yelled out, “You are not an intellectual, sir!” prompting a new round of heckling from the crowd.
Spencer warned that the audience would regret its behavior. “The forces you are enabling are going to come back to haunt you,” he said.