Houston Chronicle

Anti-abortion video to go to trial

Indicted activists reject plea deal in clinic recording

- By Brian Rogers brian.rogers@chron.com twitter.com/brianjroge­rs

Anti-abortion activists accused of falsifying records to secretly videotape Planned Parenthood officials in Houston will fight the case in court.

David Robert Daleiden, 27, and his colleague, Sandra Susan Merritt, 63, both of California, have rejected a plea deal that would have effectivel­y put an end to the criminal charges against them, their lawyers confirmed Friday.

“I don’t advise my clients to accept responsibi­lity for cases that they haven’t done anything wrong in,” said Dan Cogdell, Merritt’s attorney.

The pair were charged in January with tampering with a government­al record, a second-degree felony with a possible sentence of up to 20 years in prison. Daleiden also faces a misdemeano­r charge of attempting to buy human organs.

After a brief status hearing Friday, attorneys said they will not accept offers of pretrial diversion, a low-level probation that would have allowed the charges against them to be dismissed if they did not break the law for a year. It’s commonly offered by the Harris County District Attorney’s Office to first-time offenders with minor charges such as shopliftin­g.

Earlier this month, attorneys for Daleiden filed motions to quash the indictment­s against him, arguing that the Harris County grand jury that handed down the indictment­s was not properly empaneled.

His attorneys, Jared Woodfill and Terry Yates, have said the indictment­s are “fatally flawed.”

Harris County District Attorney Devon Anderson, a Republican, responded in a brief statement in that she had faith the charges were proper.

“These matters will be thoroughly reviewed by a judge and jury,” she said. “I am confident that the actions of the DA’s office in this case will withstand any scrutiny.”

Daleiden and Merritt are accused of using fake driver’s licenses in dealings with the women’s health organizati­on.

The grand jury also charged Daleiden with the same misdemeano­r he had accused the organizati­on of — the purchase or sale of human organs — presumably because he had offered to buy organs in an attempt to provoke Planned Parent- hood employees into saying they would sell.

The grand jury had been convened to investigat­e whether a Planned Parenthood of the Gulf Coast clinic had sold the organs of aborted fetuses. The grand jury cleared the clinic and instead indicted the undercover videograph­ers.

Prosecutor­s declined to comment.

With several reporters in attendance, Daleiden took the opportunit­y to blast Planned Parenthood, which recently has been targeted by a Republican-led congressio­nal panel called the House Select Investigat­ive Panel on Infant Lives.

Officials with Planned Parenthood have denied any wrongdoing since Daleiden and Merritt released the videos last July.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States