‘HARVEY DEALS’ THE NEW NORMAL
Makeshift hearings held as flood-damaged courthouse is repaired
State District Judge Maria Jackson stood up behind a shaky makeshift bench in the basement of the Harris County Jail and came eye to eye with an inmate in an orange jail uniform 3 feet away.
“We’re trying to get cases moving, so you need to make a decision,” the judge told the handcuffed young man accused of rape. “If you need to talk to your attorney, go ahead.”
The inmate and his lawyer took three steps back to huddle, wedged in between eight other inmates along a cinderblock wall.
Brief and overcrowded procedural hearings like this basement exchange have generated hundreds of pleas and dismissals, dubbed “Harvey deals,” in what has become the new normal for the state’s largest criminal justice system in the wake of Hurricane Harvey’s destruc-
The county’s criminal courthouse, a 20-story skyscraper that sits on the banks of Buffalo Bayou on the north side of downtown Houston, remains shuttered after it was flooded with 4 feet of water during the August storm.
Damage extended throughout the building after water seeped in through the walls and pooled in the basement, triggering a malfunction in computers that regulate the water pressure. This in turn sent water gushing through sinks, toilets and water fountains on some upper levels, causing pipes to burst and flooding courtrooms that wouldn’t otherwise have been damaged.
Now, two dingy and crowded classrooms-turned-courtrooms locked behind clanking steel doors in a jail basement have become the epicenter of an evergrowing docket of felony criminal filings.
In a small room in another jail building, the judges and prosecutors handling misdemeanors are dealing with the same pressures. The nearby Jury Assembly Building, which was built underground with a park on top, was destroyed. Another 111 county buildings sustained $127 million in damages, according to initial estimates.
Closed six more months
County Engineer John Blount said he couldn’t begin to estimate how much repairs and flood-prevention measures at the main courthouse will cost.
But he said it likely will remain closed for at least another six months, with court staff and other county employees gradually moving back into their offices and courtrooms as work is completed over the next year. For now, criminal trials are being conducted in the nearby civil courthouse.
The county is following FEMA guidelines and will be hiring consultants this month, he said.
Harris County Judge Ed Emmett said the storm affected all aspects of county government.
“Obviously, the county is working overtime and as hard as possible to get things up and running and as close to normal as we can, but it’s still going to take some time,” Emmett said.
District Attorney Kim Ogg — whose staff of 700 has scattered to nine different locations, with some as far away as the Galleria area — said the office is contending with the challenge.
“It is hard on our people and it’s hard on the public,” she said. “We’re gritting our teeth and bearing it.”
In a ballroom-sized area on the top floor of a downtown office building, almost 90 of Ogg’s 300 prosecutors work elbow-to-elbow contacting victims, witnesses and defense attorneys to hash out misdemeanor cases. Instead of being an elevator ride away from court, prosecutors are working blocks or even miles away.
“It really looks like a giant telemarketing company,” Ogg said of the makeshift misdemeanor bureau.
The DA’s office lost workspace on six floors in the criminal courthouse, and Ogg said the effort of transporting files to court is now driving an initiative to go paperless.
During an afternoon in late October, Jackson presided over a jailhouse courtroom packed with more than 20 inmates, sheriff’s deputies, court staffers, prosecutors and defense lawyers.
At one end of Jackson’s bench, a staffer handed out forms kept on an end table, fashioned from a pair of stacked milk crates. Attorneys signed forms to reschedule court hearings and piled them on the lid of a trash can.
The judge, a soft-spoken woman with silver spectacles balanced on her nose, said she was initially concerned about laying down the law to suspects just an arms-length away.
“We’re real close,” the judge said, referring to inmates near enough to make contact. “I’m not used to that. It wasn’t what I was expecting. But as long as I have at least two deputies standing there, I feel safe.”
In the adjacent courtroom, state District Judge George Powell shepherded cases through his criminal docket.
“It’s inconvenient, but everybody’s been inconvenienced. It’s not just us,” Powell said. “We don’t want (inmates’) constitutional rights violated. We want to make sure they don’t stay there any longer than they have to, and we need to get the cases moving.”
In the ‘bullpen’
Every weekday, there are two docket calls in each of the pair of classrooms where two of the 22 felony judges alternate in holding court from a “bench” consisting of two chipped wooden desks lined up end-to-end. They are trying to move the cases of inmates charged with the most serious crimes waiting to go to trial.
Within earshot of a halfdozen other inmates, criminal suspects have their only opportunity to resolve their case for at least a week, until the court to which their case is assigned holds another hearing.
Defense lawyers in sneakers shuffle between the courtrooms and a “bullpen” set up in the jail’s law library.
“It’s a tight squeeze,” said attorney Angela Weltin. “It definitely has its challenges, but everyone is doing their best to make sure these guys get a fair shake.”
In the bullpen, prosecutors and defense attorneys work out plea deals. Once an agreement is reached, the defense lawyer, the inmate and the prosecutor stand shoulder-to-shoulder in front of the judge who can approve the bargain.
Defense lawyer Carlos Rodriguez said the parties are trying to make the best of a tough situation.
“Because they can’t have court every day, when the inmates get to come to court, they really take advantage of it,” he said.
Other lawyers said the crush of criminal cases has caused judges and prosecutors to evaluate their dockets with an eye toward getting rid of as many cases as possible.
“If the case is something not so serious, you’ve got a chance at getting a ‘Harvey deal,’ ” said one lawyer, who spoke on condition of anonymity. “But if it’s serious, you get delays.”
Ogg confirmed that in the wake of the storm, her top lieutenants reviewed about 600 low-level drug cases in a feverish bid to make plea deals.
“We dismissed about 110 of those cases, and we pled about 200 others,” Ogg said. “There were about 300 that we couldn’t plead.”
Ogg said her office sought to expedite state jail felony drug cases, which typically involve possession of small amounts of cocaine or other drugs.
“I intend to continue to try to clear our table of cases that produce the least public safety benefit but suck the most resources,” she said. “And those are low-level drug cases and those that involve the mentally ill.”
Until the storm, the courthouse housed the 22 state district courts presided over by felony judges like Jackson and Powell, as well as 16 misdemeanor courts. Each day, sheriff’s deputies and detention officers escorted more than 800 inmates from the two nearby jails to courtrooms. A covered walkway extends from beneath the jail, spans Buffalo Bayou, and leads to the center of the courthouse at 1201 Franklin. In the core of the building, banks of secured elevators move inmates to dozens of holding cells in courtrooms from the eighth floor up to the 20th.
Historically, about 70 percent of the 9,000 inmates in the jail are awaiting trial, although those numbers have been going down because of recent bail reforms. Most will resolve their case with a plea deal. But the number of criminal filings, which tops more than 100,000 a year, keeps going up.
Now, deputies move 300 to 450 inmates a day from jail cells to one of seven locations, including the jail basement or substitute courtrooms in the civil, juvenile and family courthouses.
Judges and defense attorneys praised Sheriff Ed Gonzalez’s staff for maintaining an orderly process.
“It’s been a test, but it seems like, so far, we’re passing the test,” said HCSO Chief Deputy Darryl Coleman.
Family watch room
Across the bayou from the jail complex, the county’s 17-story civil courthouse has been pressed into service, with the civil and felony criminal courts doubling up in courtrooms to accommodate suspects who are out on bail.
It is still crowded, but defendants and lawyers are able to do their business in traditional courtrooms.
In a top-floor conference room divided into thirds by glass walls, big-screen TVs equipped with cameras show what’s going on blocks away in the basement of the jail. The room is carpeted, with chairs and several tables.
It’s a place for suspects’ families to view what’s going on without trying to get into the jail courtrooms.
On a Friday morning in October, an older man with a hearing aid focused on the TV and waited for his son to appear, hoping to see the case resolved.
As his adult son approached the judge and signed a form on the makeshift bench, the father stood close to the TV to hear what was going on.
A minute later, an attorney held the form up to the camera to show the case had been postponed yet again. The older man leaned toward the closed-circuit TV to make out the date scribbled on the yellow form.
Then the father, who declined to give his name, gathered up his hat and newspaper and sighed.
“Another reset,” said the man, who shook his head and left.
“It is hard on our people and it’s hard on the public. We’re gritting our teeth and bearing it.” District Attorney Kim Ogg
Judge Maria Jackson, left, listens as Stephanie Martin, a defense attorney, argues her client’s case in the 339th District Court, which is temporarily located in the basement of the Harris County Jail.
The Harris County district attorney’s misdemeanor division, which includes 88 prosecutors, works out of a makeshift office in a ballroom-size area in a county building downtown after being displaced by Hurricane Harvey.