Carbon monoxide deaths show keyless cars’ danger
For Sherry H. Penney, a former university chancellor, and her husband, James D. Livingston, a retired physicist, the 2017 Toyota Avalon was a sensible purchase. It was a model she and her husband had owned before, but the new version had electronic sensors and other advanced features.
“The Avalon is very safe,” Livingston’s daughter Susan recalled hearing Penney say.
Last month, one of those features proved fatal.
Penney, 81, and Livingston, 88, were found dead at their home in Sarasota, Fla., poisoned by carbon monoxide, according to preliminary tests by the local medical examiner. Susan Livingston said that they had neglected to turn off the car’s keyless ignition after pulling into the garage attached to their house and that the engine had continued to run.
The deaths highlight a hazard that regulatory and legislative efforts have yet to remedy: Without the motion of turning a physical key, some car owners, especially older ones, forget to turn off a vehicle.
Based on news reports, lawsuits, police and fire records, and research by advocacy groups, at least 36 people have been killed in the United States in such incidents since 2006, including seven in the past six months. Dozens of others have been injured; some left with brain damage.
The deaths of Penney and Livingston were all the more striking because of their accomplishments in academia and science. Before retiring to Florida, Penney was the first woman to serve permanently as chancellor of the University of Massachusetts Boston and held other leadership roles in the UMass and State University of New York systems. Livingston, an expert on magnets, spent decades as a researcher at General Electric and taught at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. The couple collaborated on a book about Martha Wright, a women’s rights figure in the 1800s who was James Livingston’s great-greatgrandmother.
“These are very smart people,” Susan Livingston said. “This kind of situation can happen to anybody.”
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, which oversees the auto industry, proposed a rule for keyless vehicles in 2011 mandating a one-second audible external warning to drivers to turn off the ignition. The rule would cost the auto industry $500,000 a year, according to an agency estimate. But after lobbying from the industry, the proposal has remained in limbo.
Asked recently for comment, the agency repeated earlier guidance, pointing consumers to a safety video about the use and potential dangers of keyless ignitions.
Some keyless models activate audible warnings or flashing lights inside or outside the car if the door is opened while the motor is running. The Toyota Avalon, for example, is designed to beep once internally and three times externally in such circumstances. But as the deaths of Penney and Livingston indicate, such alerts are not always adequate.
“I think if they bought a different car, they’d be alive,” Susan Livingston said.
Contacted for this article, the automaker said, “Toyota vehicles meet or exceed all regulatory safety standards.”
An investigation by the New York Times last year highlighted the extent of the hazard with keyless ignitions and the regulatory inaction. Soon after, Sen. Richard Blumenthal, DConn., demanded during a hearing that the highway safety agency adopt its proposed rule and require carmakers to make vehicles shut off automatically after a set period of idling. Earlier this year, Blumenthal introduced a bill to do just that.
The Senate legislation, the Park It Act, has yet to be scheduled for a committee hearing. But this month a group of House members — three Democrats and a Republican — introduced an identical bill in the Energy and Commerce Committee.
“This is something we clearly have the technology to prevent,” Rep. Jan Schakowsky, D-Ill., the bill’s lead House sponsor, said of the carbon-monoxide deaths.
Ford and General Motors said they support the legislation.
Some automakers added an automatic shut-off, including Ford on all its keyless vehicles since the 2015 model year. GM retrofitted some of its vehicles to add the automatic shutoff, at $5 apiece, the company told regulators.
Toyota, whose vehicles have been involved in half of the fatal incidents, has announced that its 2020 keyless models will come with an automatic shut-off function. It would not say whether it supported the congressional legislation.