Imperial Valley Press

Trump administra­tion always on the wrong side of history

- KENT BUSH

Adolf Hitler was a bad guy, but I but he did at least a few good things. He may have had a nice singing voice or perhaps he found cute kittens adorable. You have to admit, he was dedicated to his beliefs.

I still can’t imagine a circumstan­ce where I would call him honorable.

Robert E. Lee isn’t as bad as Hitler. He was a seditionis­t and led a rebellion that divided our country and cost us hundreds of thousands of lives simply to support slavery. I know. I know.

White House Chief of Staff Gen. John Kelly said Lee believed in state’s rights and he fought to defend them. He did fight for state’s rights — the right for states to keep slavery legal.

Until revisionis­t historians began trying to lessen the impact of slavery in order to be able to cling to certain tenets of institutio­nal racism, everyone knew that the Civil War was about ending the practice of slavery.

I am slow to judge people from another era by today’s cultural standards. Things were different then. George Washington owned slaves. Thomas Jefferson did too. At the time, owning people to work on a farm was culturally acceptable. Looking back, we are shocked and saddened. But at the time, preachers preached it, teachers taught it and culture accepted it.

It is 2017. We view things differentl­y now. In 1917, women couldn’t vote and interracia­l marriage wasn’t even legal in all 50 states until 1967. In 1967, the civil rights movement was rolling and overt institutio­nal racism was still very prevalent. As Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. famously stated, “Let us realize the arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice.”

In Lee’s time, owning slaves and even fighting a war to preserve that culture and economic system was not as morally abhorrent as it is today. The arc has bent far from those days and I am willing to give him a 150 years worth of a break.

That being said, Lee was anything but honorable. Not even a little bit. He didn’t just fight for his side in battle. He captured free black men and enslaved them. After a slave beating, he famously asked for the slaves to be bathed in brine to literally pour salt in the newly opened wounds. That isn’t cultural. That is cruel.

I understand the people who idolize Lincoln for preserving the unity of the country and freeing the slaves. I’ll never understand those who want to excuse the awful practices that created an American caste system and threatened to destroy the country. White House Spokespers­on Sarah Huckabee-Sanders recently said she didn’t think it was appropriat­e to debate a four star general. Like Gen. Kelly’s assertions about Gen. Lee being honorable, Sanders was wrong.

Gen. Kelly fell into a trap that has ensnared most of the people who still support President Donald Trump.

Canadian historian Margaret MacMillan once said, “We can learn from history, but we can also deceive ourselves when we selectivel­y take evidence from the past to justify what we have already made up our minds to believe.”

Sanders defended Kelly’s comments on the Civil War by saying that “just because you don’t like history doesn’t mean you can erase it and pretend it didn’t happen.” I don’t think anyone wants to change history that they don’t like. I think the thing that concerns a majority of Americans is just which part of history the people at the top of this administra­tion actually like.

Sanders was also called on to lie for the President this week after he called the federal court system “a joke and a laughing stock.” He didn’t imply or insinuate it. President Trump actually said, “what we have now is a joke and it’s a laughing stock.” It was on video with the president sitting and answering questions with many cameras pointed at him.

Sanders was quick to tell reporters just hours later that the president didn’t say that. To use Sanders own words, just because you don’t like what the president says, doesn’t mean you can erase it or pretend it didn’t happen.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States