Las Vegas Review-Journal (Sunday)
Tax law an obstacle in fixing affordable housing shortage
Last year the LIHTC program financed nearly 1,150 homes in Nevada.
As Nevada grapples with a massive shortage of affordable housing, state officials fear federal tax reform has stymied a long-standing funding resource.
Since 1986 the federal Low-Income Housing Tax Credit program has allowed private investors to reduce their federal tax liability if they help pay for the creation or rehabilitation of affordable rental housing. Last year the program financed nearly 1,150 homes and apartments in Nevada and capped their rents for at least 30 years.
“It’s by far the single-biggest program across the country to generate affordable housing units,” Nevada Housing Division Chief Financial Officer Michael Holliday said.
But the program lost some effectiveness with the December passage of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, which lowered the corporate tax rate and decreased demand for the credits, Holliday said.
He estimated that investors could be willing to pay up to 14 cents less for each dollar of tax credits. That adds up over time.
National accounting firm Novogradac & Company estimates 1,730 fewer affordable rental units will be built in Nevada over the next decade.
“It’s going to be marginal, but it’s going to be repetitively marginal,” Holliday said of the loss. “If it weren’t for the fact that interest rates are going up, cost of (construction) materials
are going up, land prices are going up, it would be easier to overcome the change in tax credit pricing. … Combined with those other pressures it’s a big deal.”
Success story
In the state’s two most populous counties, Clark and Washoe, the Housing Division estimates about 197,000 more affordable rentals are needed.
A 2016 Housing Division report found rentals built and preserved through the tax-credit program had waiting lists of close to 9,500 households, up 18 percent from the previous year.
Las Vegas-based nonprofit and developer Nevada HAND offered some relief in September, when it opened Boulder Pines Family Apartments.
Rent at the 264-unit complex on Boulder Highway is based on each tenant’s income, which averages $30,000 a year. A two-bedroom apartment with granite countertops and a laundry room can rent for as low as $567 a month, almost $400 cheaper than the area’s average rent. A public charter school is next door, and a playground and pool are being built in the complex.
Last month Nevada HAND CEO
Mike Mullin shared the success story with a bipartisan committee of Nevada lawmakers studying affordable housing. Tax credits allowed the nonprofit to snag $19.3 million in private investment that funded nearly half the complex’s construction costs. Mullin estimated the project would garner at least $3.3 million less in credits under the tax deal.
“This development would not happen if we did it today,” he told lawmakers.
Looking at ‘root cause’
Others see the devaluation of tax credits as an opportunity to explore alternative avenues for financing affordable housing.
Cato Institute researcher and policy analyst Vanessa Brown Calder said there’s now more pressure on local governments to address the “root cause” of increasing housing costs: restrictive zoning and land use regulations.
“Affordable housing is the responsibility of state governments, not the federal government,” she said.
State Sen. Julia Ratti, D-Sparks, chair of the interim legislative committee studying affordable housing, said lawmakers are looking into how Nevada can help close the financing gap. However, any substantial change will have to wait until the 2019 Legislature session.
“It’s the worst possible time to be getting less bang for our buck in affordable housing strategies,” she said. “Obviously affordable housing is one of the top critical needs for the state of Nevada, and the resources we have to finance affordable housing projects are already insufficient.”