Tool vs. sanctuary cities: Liability
Bill would let cities be sued for crimes by those they release
Congressional Republicans are pushing a new tactic to combat sanctuary cities: make it easier to sue them.
That effort, part of an immigration bill in the House, threatens to undermine sanctuary policies across California by making jurisdictions that refuse to cooperate with immigration authorities liable for some crimes committed by undocumented immigrants they release.
The bill, scheduled for a vote this week, also would provide a path to citizenship for young undocumented immigrants but restrict legal immigration, limit asylum claims and budget $25 billion for the construction of a border wall and other border security measures.
It’s the culmination of weeks of talks and has the backing of President Donald Trump and House Speaker Paul Ryan, R-wis. Most Democrats are expected to oppose the bill, and some conservatives have argued against it as well.
The bill’s section on sanctuary policies is the latest example of the Trump administration’s confrontation with cities such as Oakland and San Jose and states such as California that protect undocumented immigrants.
Under the bill, jurisdictions that decline requests from federal immigration authorities to detain undocumented immigrants in their custody could face lawsuits if an immigrant they release were to commit murder, rape or sexual abuse of a child. The victim of the crime or the victim’s relative would be allowed to sue the jurisdiction if the immigrant were convicted of the crime and sentenced to at least one year in prison. States that have sanctuary policies affecting local governments also could be sued.
Trump has highlighted crimes committed by undocumented immigrants during his campaign and presidency, including the death of Kate Steinle, who was shot by an undocumented immigrant in San Francisco. Jose Ines Garcia Zarate was acquitted of murder by a jury last year. Steinle’s family sued San Francisco over her death, but their claim against the city was thrown out by a federal judge.
Meanwhile, under the bill, the federal government would step in to defend jurisdictions that do cooperate with immigration authorities if they’re sued for doing so.