Next stop: Moon or Mars?
White House, astronauts disagree about immediate target
CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. — Fifty years after humanity’s first lunar footsteps, the moon has landed back in NASA’S court.
The White House wants U.S. astronauts on the moon by 2024. The moon will serve as a critical proving ground, the thinking goes, for the real prize of sending astronauts to Mars in the 2030s.
The billionaires’ space club is on board. Amazon’s Jeff Bezos and Virgin Galactic’s Richard Branson favor moon before Mars. Spacex’s Elon Musk also is rooting for the moon, although his heart is on colonizing Mars.
But Apollo 11 astronaut Michael Collins prefers a beeline to Mars. Buzz Aldrin, too, is a longtime Mars backer. Back in 1994 on the 25th anniversary of his moon landing with Neil Armstrong, Aldrin questioned whether astronauts would be back on the moon by the 50th anniversary, let alone on Mars, which then was the short-lived goal.
Fast-forward to the golden anniversary, and NASA doesn’t even have the capability to get astronauts into orbit around Earth. Russians are launching American astronauts to the International Space Station — for high prices — until capsules built by Spacex and Boeing are ready. That likely won’t happen until next year, almost a decade after NASA’S space shuttle program ended.
“Fifty years ago … we landed, explored,got back up again, rendezvoused, came back. That’s 50 years of non-progress,” Aldrin groused this month during an anniversary bash. “I think we all ought to be a little ashamed that we can’t do better than that.”
Collins, who circled the moon in the mother ship while Aldrin and Armstrong planted a U.S. flag and gathered rocks, acknowledges that returning to the moon as a steppingstone to Mars is “a valid plan.”
“But I don’t have to agree with it,” Collins said. “I would take what I call the John F. Kennedy approach and I’d say if you want to go to
Mars, you say you want to go to Mars and you go.”
Even President Donald Trump — whose vice president is out there plugging moonshots — prefers talking up Mars.
In an Oval Office meeting with Aldrin and Collins on the eve of the landing anniversary, Trump asked if it was possible to send astronauts to Mars without revisiting the moon. Collins replied yes.
“Who knows better than these people, right? They’ve been doing this stuff for a long time,” the president said.
Despite a lack of human presence on the moon, robotic spacecraft are exploring the gray, dusty world.
NASA’S Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter has been circling the moon for the past 10 years. This year, China landed a craft on the far side of the moon. And on Monday, India plans to launch a mission to the moon’s south pole.