Las Vegas Review-Journal

What happened to old-fashioned civility?

- SUSAN ESTRICH Susan Estrich is a USC law professor and Democratic political activist.

THE president didn’t seem to mind. When Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene couldn’t restrain herself from calling out “liar,” he was ready. When others started booing, he took them on.

The president smiled and veered off his teleprompt­er. He was at his best. Let Biden be Biden. But what does it say about us?

The British do it this way, I suppose. They’re used to this kind of parliament­ary debate.

I grew up with a different tradition. Respect for the presidency. Civility at important moments. I worked in the Senate in the 1980s. President Ronald Reagan was in office. The thought that someone would boo him in his State of the Union was simply unimaginab­le. Had it happened, that person would have been scorned. The Democrats would have been ridiculed for failing to show proper respect. Tip O’neill, then the Democratic speaker, would have none of it. Times were different. In that respect, they were better.

In 2009, when a member interrupte­d President Barack Obama’s State of the Union to shout him down, saying, “you lie,” it was so shocking that he was censured by the House.

It wasn’t so long ago that a joint session of Congress was a kind of holy occasion, where members were expected to treat the leader of the free world with a modicum of respect, not like the nightly mudslingin­g on cable news. No more.

There is something that is very sad to me about the denigratio­n of the State of the Union into another occasion for partisan political catfightin­g at its most childish level, with the people who hold themselves out as the leaders of the greatest democracy on earth behaving like children in kindergart­en. In the hallowed halls of the Capitol, they play like naughty children, calling out names, booing and refusing to listen.

But why should we be surprised?

This is what politics has become. The screamers are in charge. Marjorie Taylor Greene is ascendant. The Ronald Reagan/tip O’neill tradition is dead.

Of course it’s true that in the morning, the Republican­s will work to defeat the Biden agenda. I hope there are at least a few of them who were also elected to accomplish something by searching for common ground, a more difficult but also more rewarding task than just yelling “liar” from the rafters. And I hope there will be Democrats who will reach out and work with them to do so, so that the legislativ­e process accomplish­es more than the cable talk shows do.

All of that, however, is for the morning after. The question for the State of the Union is whether there is any room left for respect and civility in the business of politics, where we show how we work together even when we disagree on the specifics, where we show the mutual respect we must have, where we set an example for others to follow, of respect and cooperatio­n and not of antagonism and hate.

We don’t need more yelling and screaming. We don’t need more partisan name-calling. It’s cheap. It’s useless. It’s demeaning, an excuse for entertainm­ent. It debases the State of our Union.

 ?? ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States